Brown Butter Sage Apple Pie (and Enid’s Apple Pie Bake-Off recap)

Things I like about fall: apples… sage… toasty, nutty flavors like browned butter… Oh wait, I guess I’m only referring to food I like in the fall. I have a one-track mind much of the time. Good thing there are occasions for such obsessiveness, one annual Brooklyn tradition being the apple pie contest at Enid’s.

Whoever came up with the idea for this bake-off four six years ago could not have predicted the throngs of hopeful bakers that would rush to its gates. This year’s contest again trumped the previous year’s turnout with forty-three apple pies in competition. With the line spilling out of the doorway when I arrived, just a few minutes past deadline-time, I was able to observe that most of these contestants were locals, young, and yes, hipsters. With a whole lot of baking chops, no less. What’s happening to this neighborhood? A viable cook-off revolution? I can’t help but hope that I may have helped to inspire the insanity.

a glimpse at some of the 42 goodies

an overwhelmed check-in area

This was my first time entering the contest. I didn’t have any high expectations, but wanted only to make a memorable-tasting pie. After doing some tinkering with brown butter steeped in sage recently, I thought that these might lend a savory, seasonal presence to fresh-baked apples, surrounded with a buttery, slightly salty crust.

brown butter solids sink to the bottom along with sage

Brown butter has a one-of-a-kind flavor that’s really quite impossible not to love (especially in the fall). It’s no wonder the French sometimes call it beurre noisette, or hazelnut butter, because of its rich, nutty flavor and golden-brown tone. And this all happens just from cooking the butter over for about a minute. That’s what I call food science — simplified. I rolled sage leaves lengthwise and sliced them thinly (to chiffonade, as I learned from Michael) to infuse in the butter, and that made for sage brown butter. Next, I gave my sliced apples a minimal coat of both sugar and spices, and tossed them with more sage slivers — sorry, chiffonades — for a little extra herbal prominence.

I generally don’t place much emphasis on decoration but because sage leaves have such a distinct, lovely shape I decided to play up this theme on the crust. I first cut four sage-shaped slits in the top crust, and used the cut-out pieces to place on the top. It looked kind of sparse, so I cut a few more leaves from extra dough and decided to affix them asymmetrically, sort of like a scattering of fall leaves. Brushed with cream for golden color and a sprinkle of sugar in the raw, and it was into the oven.

making a dent in the dough with the top of the pie pan gives you a good guideline as to where to cut

As usual, I didn’t make a test batch so the pie I brought to the cook-off was my first go at the recipe. If it sounds ludicrous that it cinched third place against the forty-two other contenders that evening, it is — because as you might have noticed above, all of the pies were pretty ludicrously delicious-looking and diverse. What isn’t so surprising is who won second place, announced just after my award was.

we did it! (again x 2)

Yeah, as I’ve said a few times on this blog, Karol just wins. This was her second second-place prize at Enid’s apple pie contest, and to keep her title she baked this mighty precious-looking, supernaturally tasty pie.

the judges complimented the tight lattice weave

I stuck a ceremonial sage sprig through the center of mine

And for first place, a round of applause for perseverance: the duo of Sam Rio and his girlfriend (whose name I missed) have entered and have come close to greatness at Enid’s before, and finally pulled through with the big win. When I asked Sam what he did with his pie, his response: “Oh it’s really basic, it has rosemary and truffle salt in it.” (!!!) This, folks, may be some insight into a very Brooklyn cook-off-skewed mind.

guest DJ Jonathan Toubin reads off the winners

There were of course the special categories. The title for “Most Pretty” was given to a woman named Cheryl, I believe, whose pie had a picture-perfect application of pastry leaves (leaf cut-outs were a big thing this year). For the “Just Like Mom’s” category, a woman whose name I didn’t catch (holler if you’re out there!) won, and I heard later that the judges had an interesting pow-wow over what exactly this title meant. Emily Farris felt that the slightly hard, irregular-shaped pieces of apples inside the winning pie were reminiscent of her mom’s charmingly imperfect baking. Harry Rosenblum scratched his head and said that it might mean “most basic.” (Indeed, among the table of the forty-three pies there were only maybe five that you could say looked “basic.”) Finally, a new category was announced that night, to reflect the three or four pies that incorporated both ingredients: “Best Pie with Bacon and Cheese.” That award went to Alex of Blondie & Brownie, for a happy marriage of bacon and Gruyere.

and the able-stomached judges are: Rob Sheffield, music writer; Harry Rosenblum, of The Brooklyn Kitchen

Brian Campbell, husband/sous chef of last year’s pie champ; Rachel Wharton, Food & Wine senior online editor

Emily Farris, Casserole Lady

Now, you might have noticed that I’m chummy with two or three of the judges on this particular panel, and smell favoritism in the works. But I can assure you — and just confirmed with a likewise hungover Emily, who kindly closed out my bar tab that I left open at Enid’s — that the judges had no idea whose pie was whose. When I arrived, the place was so swamped that I’m not sure who took my pie to the table, or where the judges were. I think an extra-special award needs to be handed out to all five of them, for dutifully eating, tasting and critiquing those dozens of desserts.

Now, if you’re ready to bake the third-best pie in Brooklyn, here’s the magic formula!

Brown Butter Sage Apple Pie
(makes one 9″ pie)

for the filling:
6 cups tart baking apples, peeled, cored and thinly sliced
1/4 cup brown sugar
1/4 cup sugar
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
1/4 teaspoon nutmeg
1/4 teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
1/4 cup plus 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
12-15 sage leaves, rolled and thinly sliced into chiffonades

for the crust:
3/4 cup unsalted butter
2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1 1/4 teaspoons salt
3-4 tablespoons cold water
milk, cream or egg wash for brushing
sugar (preferably in the raw) for sprinkling

Combine the flour and salt for the crust and cut in the butter using a pastry blender, food processor or your hands until the mixture resembles a coarse meal. Gradually add the water a splash at a time until the dough is just moist enough to form a ball. Divide into two balls, cover each with plastic and chill while you prepare the rest.

Heat 1/4 cup of butter in a small saucepan over medium heat. Add about half the sage, and cook until the butter just begins to stop fizzing with bubbles and turns a light caramel hue. Remove from heat (the butter will continue to cook while it is off the stove, so the eventual color should be a more amber, brownish hue). Let cool. Mix the apples, lemon juice, sugars, spices, salt and the rest of the sage in a large bowl until well combined. Add the cooled brown butter and toss to mix throughout.

Roll out the pastry dough and line a 9″ pie pan with the bottom crust. Pour in apple mixture and even out the top with a spatula. Cut the remaining 2 tablespoons of butter into thin slices and place evenly on top of the apples. Top with the top crust (decorated/cut out in whatever manner you please, but making sure to poke some holes in the top to let air out). Crimp edges however you please. Brush with the egg wash/milk/cream and sprinkle with some sugar. Bake pie in a preheated 375 degree oven for about 30 minutes. Let cool about 20 minutes or more before serving for best results.

Cost Calculator
(for one pie)

6 apples (from a $3 bag of 8 at the Greenmarket): $2.25
about 1/3 of a $2 bunch of sage: $0.67
1 stick plus 2 tablespoons butter (from a $3.79 lb of European-style Plugra): $2.10
1/4 cup brown sugar: $0.20
1/4 cup sugar: $0.15
juice from half a lemon: $0.17
cinnamon, nutmeg, salt, sugar for dusting, cream for brushing: $0.20

Total: $5.74

Health Factor


Eight brownie points: It’s true, when cooking for crowds (and especially for judges) I throw health concerns out the window. This pie is a monster of calories from saturated fat, no doubt. And it will eat you, if you don’t eat it first.

Green Factor


Six maple leaves: Great luck that this cook-off was on a Sunday, which meant that I could get super-fresh ingredients from the Greenmarket on Saturday. The apples, though bruised in some places they were, were crisp and really fresh — also thanks to the beginning of the harvest season. The sage was picked up there as well. I could have gone for butter, but at Fairway one day I decided to pick up some high-fat, unsalted European-style butter from, well, Europe. I’m sure there’s a less fossil fuel-burning option that’s similar out there.

20 Responses

  1. Sarah
    |

    I love sage with fruit. What a great idea for a pie!

  2. Culinarywannabe
    |

    Congrats! I never would have thought about sage in an apple pie. I’m sure you will be having requests for this to make a reappearance on turkey day!

  3. karol
    |

    good times and congratulations again! your pie was divine and inspired, as usual.

    i actually came in 3rd last year, not 2nd, so i guess i’m moving up (although i’ll always look like a maniac in cookoff victory photos). i still can’t believe there were 40+ pies! my only regret is not at least trying any of the bacon apple pies. and truffle salt?! what’s that???

  4. kiki
    |

    Oh good lord woman! Will you ever cease to amaze me? After a long weekend of eating and drinking (and a Monday of coming back to my senses), I “officially” am eating healthy as of today. Except I’m going to have to make this pie over the weekend! This looks so dang good, my mouth is totally watering.

    Thanks, as always, for the inspiration.

  5. Michelle
    |

    my friends and i were raving about your sage apple pie that night! it was, by far, my favorite – i also tend to go more for the savory than the sweet. great job!

  6. te
    |

    Love to have this pie for Thanksgiving.
    Aunt Ellen and Phoebe are coming.

  7. midge pingleton
    |

    Congrats on 3rd place! This pie looks and sounds delish.

  8. maria
    |

    This was actually the 6th apple pie bake-off. 6 years ago, a group of us (that included the owners of Enid’s) went apple picking upstate. We came back with so many apples, we decided a bake-off would be fun. So we did it and it has been so much fun that we’ve kept doing it.

  9. Amanda
    |

    Wow–that pie sounds really great! I love pies that aren’t overly sweet.

  10. Sheryl
    |

    I won prettiest pie. Thanks for the shout out. It was my first time in the competition and I most enjoyed talking to everyone about their recipes and approaches. Unfortunately I was not able to get a taste of your brown butter and sage, alas it was gone by the time I got there!

  11. […] ever done. I didn’t try to get creative with the flavors in the filling, like adding herbs or browned butter or nuts. Just this good fruit would be sensational enough, I figured. Since there was a hoard of […]

  12. apple pie | brooklyn supper
    |

    […] sample any of the other winner’s pies, but the third place winner did tell me she had made a brown butter and sage pie and that sounds absolutely fantastic. Check out her site for a great recap of the night from a […]

  13. jaime
    |

    was there any corn starch involved in this pie? it was super delicious but extremely runny my first time making it, last year. i saw a similar recipe (without the brown butter & sage of course) that was nearly identical save for about 1 tablespoon and 1 teaspoon of corn starch. i’m wondering if that would make this less runny/soggy. i’m not well versed on pies, so i was just curious what i possibly did differently/wrong!

  14. […] placing in either the looks or taste category, but I’m not holding my breath. There are some great bakers in Brooklyn, but I think I’ve got a winner up my sleeve (and no, I’m not […]

  15. […] and I had a blast mingling at this thing.  Shortly after arriving we ran into Cathy Erway, whose bloggings had prepared us for what to expect at Enid’s apple pie contest. We filled her in on our big […]

  16. […] apple butter sage crostata… delicious and subtle tasting dessert, who could’ve guess a little punch of sage can brighten your apple crostata?? […]

  17. white truffles uk
    |

    white truffles uk…

    […]Brown Butter Sage Apple Pie (and Enid’s Apple Pie Bake-Off recap) » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  18. Scanners
    |

    Scanners…

    […]Brown Butter Sage Apple Pie (and Enid’s Apple Pie Bake-Off recap) » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  19. Cheap
    |

    Cheap…

    […]Brown Butter Sage Apple Pie (and Enid’s Apple Pie Bake-Off recap) » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  20. The Brownie Boy
    |

    The Brownie Boy…

    […]Brown Butter Sage Apple Pie (and Enid’s Apple Pie Bake-Off recap) » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

Leave a Reply