Plum & Apricot Pie

posted in: Desserts, Pies, Recipes | 14

We’ve gotten our first whiff of fall in New York City this week. This morning, I actually put on socks. But now that summer is beginning to fade (and soon, too, will my flip-flop foot tan), it’s officially okay to start thinking about baking, specifically pies. There is so much good fruit around.

Fresh, tree-ripe peaches, plums and apricots make a superior pie, and this is the only time of year to get them. I can’t tell you how sad it is to try a canned peach-filled pie after trying one made with the ripest fruit, fresh. Another great reason to make pies from these fruits — as tempting as they are to just gobble up fresh — is that it’s a great way to use up fruits that have gotten a little bruised, or are soft and overripe, just like turning them into jam.

multi-colored plums from Red Jacket Orchards

So that’s what happened with a bunch of apricots and plums recently, for me. Though I’ve been eating plums incessantly ever since I signed up for Red Jacket Orchard’s fruit CSA, I can’t seem to down enough of them before they get a little soft and squishy. I prefer eating plums that are slightly firm, when the skin’s tight across its ruby flesh and super tart. A couple of pints of apricots, too, went the way of soft and slightly shriveled, as if they were on their way to drying themselves out in the sun on their own. Not even the brewers at Sixpoint could finish all the fresh fruits that I had stocked the fridge with. So one day, for a post-lunch dessert, I made this pie.

making a quick pie pastry from butter, flour and water

It was the quickest pie-making mission I think I’ve ever done. I didn’t try to get creative with the flavors in the filling, like adding herbs or browned butter or nuts. Just this good fruit would be sensational enough, I figured. Since there was a hoard of plums and apricots, I went with those for my theme, and left the skins on as I pitted and cut them all into wedges.

fresh (overripe) apricots and plums tossed with sugar form the filling

The good thing about this mix, plums and apricots, is that apricots are a little on the dry side, and plums can be way too mushy when baked. Combined, they make not only a great flavor, but a nice consistency in your pie. Just be sure to add a little touch of cornstarch (or flour) to the fruit mixture, so that the runny plum juices thicken up a bit into a delicious sauce.

the top crust is assembled (and I forgot to poke holes for ventilation!)

an egg wash is prepared (from one of Beaker’s miniature eggs)

and brushed on, followed by a sprinkle of sugar

Something about cooked apricots and plums, too, is just delicious in a way that completely differs from how they taste fresh. You don’t need to add lemon juice to this pie filling, either — it’s tangy and very intense in flavor alone. I don’t know why people invented candy sometimes.

If you find yourself in a predicament of too much fruit, too, or just want to try out this combo for a ride, please do so before stone fruit season’s over. It might just warm you up to colder weather soon to come.

Plum & Apricot Pie
(makes one 9-inch pie)

for the filling
6 cups plums and apricots, pitted and cut to wedges
1/2 cup sugar
2 teaspoons cornstarch

for the crust
1 1/2 sticks cold unsalted butter, cubed
2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon salt
2-3 tablespoons cold water
optional: 1 egg and sugar to brush on top before baking

Make the crust: Combine the flour and salt. Using a pastry blender, your fingers or a food processor, cut the butter into the flour. If using the food processor, pulse several few times until the pieces of butter are no larger than a pea. The mixture should resemble coarse crumbs. Add water one tablespoon at a time and stop when the dough is malleable enough to form a ball. (If using food processor, slowly add water one tablespoon at a time to the mixture while pulsing it just until a ball is formed). Break into two balls. Cover them with plastic wrap and chill at least 30 minutes. (Crust can be made several hours beforehand.)

In a large bowl, combine the fruit with the sugar and cornstarch and mix well. Roll one pastry ball out and transfer to the bottom of a 9-inch pie pan. Fill with the fruit. Roll out top crust on a sheet of waxed or parchment paper, and carefully transfer peel off on top of the pie. Crimp edges to seal the pie shut, and poke holes throughout the top with a fork to ventilate the filling. Brush top of pie with the beaten egg mixed with a little water, and sprinkle the top of the pie with sugar. Bake at 375 degrees for about 40 minutes, or until lightly browned on top.

Cost Calculator
(for 1 9-inch pie, or about 8 servings)

6 cups apricots and plums (from a CSA half-share at $13 per week of lots of fruit): $5.00
1 1/2 sticks butter (at $3.50/8 oz.): $2.63
2 1/4 cups flour: $1.50
1/2 cup sugar: $0.25
1 teaspoon salt, 2 teaspoons cornstarch, sugar for sprinkling, egg for eggwash from rooftop chicken): $0.25

Total: $9.63

Health Factor

Seven brownie points: A rich pie pastry filled with sugared, cooked fruit is what it is, no matter how fresh and full of vitamins the fruit is to begin with. Still, they retain a good share of Vitamin C, telling by the pie’s tartness, and by keeping the skins of the fruit on you’re keeping more flavor as well as nutrition, so don’t go through the hassle of peeling! One piece of this treat is a good way to reconcile with an overload of fruit, but whenever you can, eating them fresh is the best way to go for your health.

Green Factor

Eight maple leaves: Know thy farmer, they say, and it’s been a great pleasure getting to know the farmers and staff at Red Jacket Orchards, which doesn’t spray chemicals on their Finger Lakes-based orchard and is fond of cultivating rare varieties of fruits to keep them alive. The butter, from Ronnybrook, is also created with care by the upstate dairy. I’ll just need to join a grain CSA next in order to benefit from all the great flour made in this region.

14 Responses

  1. sara

    Yum, this pie looks amazing! Delish. 🙂

  2. Kate

    Ooooh tasty! This inspires me to clean out the farmer’s market for peaches and plums, to bake about 10 of these pies, and to freeze them. Then, in the doldrums of January, there will be pie!

  3. Joslyn @ missfitbliss

    Beautiful colors! I love pretty food.

  4. City Share

    What a beautiful pie! I have never tried a plum pie, but I’m sure it’s delicious. Thanks for the suggestion of combining plums and apricots.

  5. josh

    Cathy you truly are the best! In honor of your awesomeness, my brother and I, over at, are going to make a version of this pie and give it away for free on my site. Delivered personally to your house.

  6. josh

    not to YOUR house, to the winners house… woops 🙂

  7. cathy

    Hey that’s okay, too, Josh!

  8. josh

    alright fine, maybe I WILL deliver you a pie to your new pad.

  9. Nice post!

  10. Erika

    This looks amazing! I love an interesting fruit pie — and this looks like a winner to bring along to dinner parties.

  11. […] Plum and Apricot Pie from Not Eating Out in New York […]

  12. fds


  13. Tammy

    Tried this today!! it was delicious!!

  14. Digger

    The combination of fruits were great but must admit I like my pastry to be an even brown all over looks so much better and eats nicer.

Leave a Reply