Incredible Vegetable Cassoulet


For a long time, I could never fathom making many beloved, wintry foods without meat. It seemed like if you took the meat away, you’d lose the whole hutzpah of the thing. And besides, we need something to fortify our chilled bones with. Well, it’s taken a long journey but in the case of cassoulet, I’ve decided that it isn’t the pork, or duck fat that is the whole hutzpah, it’s the tender, melt-in-your-mouth beans swaddled in a creamy, baked-in sauce.

Most meat-lovers may never come around to this determination, but stranger things have happened. In lieu of animal fat, I created a rich, dark roux as a base and peppered the whole thing with plenty of vegetables for a depth of flavor. The resulting cassoulet (yes, I’m still going to call it that) has a pleasing, sweet-savory taste and velvety mouthfeel that is quite addicting in a totally harmless way.

Is it really that non-traditional? Well, maybe not if you consider that this dish, like paella or gumbo, has very homely origins. Cassoulet, like many other types of humble, vegetable-based foods, was traditionally a repository for any scraps of meat and fat one could spare, giving the cooked beans a hearty flavor. Sausages (themselves a repository for said bits) are common to find buried among the beans, and if observing the last two years of the Greenmarket Cassoulet Cook-Off at Jimmy’s No. 43 says anything, duck fat is seen as an inseparable ingredient among modern interpreters, too.

usual suspects: carrot, celery and parsnip

I know, sounds delicious, right? But I also know (from being one of those cook-off contestants, and from talking to the others) that those ingredients can jack up the cost of your cassoulet by an egregious margin. Especially when you’re making a very large portion of it, which you might as well do even when not serving a huge room, since it takes a while to cook. And that’s one area I’m not going to cut corners on — cooking it properly. There’s little attraction to “al dente” beans.

green flageoulets, a prized bean for cassoulet

How long they need to cook and how much liquid should you add varies depending on the beans. If they aren’t tender by the time you finish the recipe below, add some more cooking liquid and give it some more time. Keep in mind that if your beans are larger than the fancy, French flageoulet beans that I’m using here (or smaller, such as with Navy beans), you might need less of both. Just don’t use canned beans here; you want the beans to soak in all the flavors of the cassoulet as they cook.

butter and flour are combined over low heat

half an hour later, as chestnut roux

Next step was developing the roux, which can be done while chopping or doing other things — just give the pot a scrape of your spatula now and then. Roux, an essential French cooking technique that gives way to all types of sauces afterwards, is just flour, butter and stirring. As the butter bubbles, the flour slightly burns, or caramelizes, to any desired depth of color (and flavor). I stopped stirring once mine had reached a deep “chestnut” brown. Its smell kind of reminds me of buttered burnt toast.

crimini mushrooms

Then, it’s a matter of building flavor upon flavor. I wanted some of the vegetables in this to stand out more than others, so I cooked down my carrot-onion-celery mirepoix for quite a while before adding the next ingredient, mushrooms. I liked the idea of having chunky vegetables strewn about, so I chopped these into sizable wedges. For about half of the cooking liquid, I poured from a mason jar of fresh tomato sauce that I’d canned over the summer; cooking down a couple fresh tomatoes right into this mixture should do instead just fine. One of the last additions before popping this big pot into the oven was a couple handfuls of big chunks of raw squash. These cooked down to incredibly delicious, loose sponges of orange when it was all served up. They’re a delight to come across, and I found myself picking them all onto my plate when it was time for seconds.

deglazed, and ready to bake

If you’re not convinced after trying this recipe that it is the most incredible vegetable cassoulet you’ve ever had (or the best cassoulet of any kind), then come down and share your recipe at the 3rd Annual Cassoulet Cook-Off, on January 22. It’s a benefit for the Greenmarket, and I’ll be one of the judges this time. Don’t worry, I’ll gladly eat your pork or duck fat, if that’s what you go with!

Incredible Vegetable Cassoulet
(makes 4-6 servings)

1 cup dry beans (preferably cannellini beans or flageoulets)
1 carrot, finely diced
1 medium onion, finely diced
2 stalks celery, finely diced and keeping the leaves, if any
1 small parsnip, peeled and finely diced
about 1/2 lb butternut, acorn, buttercup, or similar winter squash, chopped to coarse, 1-2″ pieces
about 1/4 lb crimini mushrooms, quartered
1 cup apple cider
1 cup fresh tomato sauce (or substitute 2-3 fresh tomatoes, chopped)
3 cloves garlic
2 bay leaves
1/2 bunch fresh thyme
a few sage leaves, chopped (optional)
a sprig rosemary, chopped (optional)
1-2 cups fresh breadcrumbs (optional)
sea salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste
for the roux:
4 tablespoons butter
1/4 cup all-purpose flour

Soak beans overnight. Drain. Pour boiling water over beans to cover by at least 3 inches and cover. Let sit for 1 hour, and drain.

In a large, cast-iron Dutch oven (or “cassoulet”), melt the butter and add the flour. Keep heat on low and stir occasionally for about 30 minutes, until roux is a medium, reddish chestnut-brown.

Add the onion, carrot, celery and parsnip. Season with salt and pepper and cook, stirring occasionally, on low heat. Add an extra tablespoon of butter if mixture feels very dry and is sticking too much to the bottom of the pot. Cook until all vegetables have reduced in size and released most of their juices, so that the pot is becoming dry again. Add the mushrooms, garlic, and the herbs. Once mushrooms have softened a little and garlic is fragrant, deglaze pot with the apple cider. Add the squash, bay leaves, tomato sauce, generous pinches of salt and pepper, and the drained beans.

Place cover on pot and transfer to a preheated 325-degree oven. Cook for 2 hours. Remove lid and check beans for tenderness. If beans are not soft enough and mixture is becoming too dry, add a little more tomato sauce or vegetable stock and cover again. If not, sprinkle the optional breadcrumbs across the top of the cassoulet, season with salt and pepper, and cook uncovered for another 15-20 minutes or until breadcrumbs are golden. Let cool a few minutes before serving.

Cost Calculator
(for 4-6 servings)

1 cup fancy green flageoulet beans: $2.99
1 carrot: $0.25
2 stalks celery: $0.35
1 parsnip: $0.40
1 onion: $0.40
about 1/4 acorn squash: $1.00
about 1/2 bunch thyme (from an “herb wreath” bought over Christmas): $1.00
1/4 lb crimini mushrooms: $3.00
1 cup apple cider: $0.50
1 cup homemade canned tomato sauce: $0.75
4 tablespoons butter: $0.50
flour, salt, pepper, bay leaves, garlic: $0.50

Total: $11.64

Health Factor

Three brownie points: This is the kind of meal in one pot that you can be really proud of. Buttery roux and all, most of the natural starches that lend to a rich texture come from the beans themselves, as well as the other veggies. From the beans, you’ll get protein and fiber aplenty, as it still holds a healthy majority to everything else in the dish (no pun intended). Vitamin A, C and antioxidants will power through those carrots, celery, and your fresh tomatoes. Parsnips are great sources of potassium, mushrooms are full of selenium, and the winter squash has pretty much all of the above. Cooking most of these vegetables decreases their potency of many of the vitamins mentioned, admittedly, but perhaps that’s more reason to pack this dish it with large quantities of them.

Green Factor

Six maple leaves: It’s getting grim at the Greenmarket, and for local vegetables that aren’t totally frostbitten yet. You could fill the recipe with just root vegetables, I suppose, but onions and celery really round it out well. So I got those from an average grocery store, and they’re not local nor organic. However, the tomato sauce, which really helps to add a brightness to the overall flavor, was from fresh tomatoes I put up in the summer when I got Jersey beefsteaks in bulk; and the apple cider from one too many cartons I bought in the fall. I guess this recipe is for the most part Greenmarket-friendly at this time of year — that is, easy to source locally in a pretty cold and snowy region.

27 Responses

  1. Pearl
    |

    wow, that sounds fabulous. putting it on the list to try.

  2. Dave
    |

    Great post Cathy — I love the idea of using a rich dark roux in place of the meatiness of the missing meat!

  3. Kerry Kenney
    |

    thanks for taking so much time to write this up. It is a completely foreign dish for me but I will tackle it!

  4. Katie
    |

    This looks like a comforting dish to say the least! I can’t say I’m a “beany” person but I think I’ll give it a go! This 10-degree weather is just begging for something hearty on the table!

  5. naomi dagen bloom
    |

    Cathy, Your delightful blog has been on my blogroll for a while now–though we left NYC for Portland, Oregon. Pleased to see that your book will soon be here where eating out is more seductive and reasonable than the big apple.

    Just got religion via the new movie “Forks over Knives.” Both the cassoluet and cauliflower recipes will help keep us on the path to more plants on the home menu. Thanks, naomi

  6. blepharisma
    |

    The roux is such a great idea. I made a veggie version, too, and I was wondering how to replace the meat/onion puree that I saw in some of the meaty recipes. This would do just fine! I also think it’s odd that cassoulet has become such an expensive endeavour (with the duck fat and meats and things), since it’s supposed to be peasant food.

  7. a-man
    |

    Looks great that cassoulet! Nice with the beans.

  8. […] is something I’ve never made and always wanted to. This vegetarian version looks pretty good and would fit in nicely with my diet […]

  9. Lauren
    |

    I made this and it was supremely delicious, but the beans never really got soft. I forgot to put a lid on the beans once I covered them with hot water…could that have been the problem?

  10. Marcie
    |

    I found the taste of the vinegar to be very strong, even after almost three hours of baking. Is the amount correct? Next time I think I will use 1/2 cup diluted with 1/2 cup vegetable stock or water. I also found that the beans were still hard after 2 hours of baking—they were fine, but still firm, after three.

  11. Amy
    |

    Thanks for the inspiration! I made it with ingredients I had on hand, which meant not all of the vegetables and a red wine/chicken broth sub for the apple cider. It turned out sooo good and leftovers are incredible. I can’t really imagine that meat would improve on this, maybe on the side would be okay.

  12. Kate
    |

    Making this right now (with a few small changes). Smells wonderful – can’t wait to dig in!

  13. Caroline
    |

    I’m excited about this and will try it. But you should rethink your use of “chutzpah” because it doesn’t work here.

  14. Christina
    |

    I had to stop myself from eating the entire celery/carrot/parsnip/onion/roux mixture alone. This is a fantastic recipe.

  15. anna
    |

    yum – have tried sometihng like it but with chestnuts and puy lentils in the mix instead of mushrooms.

  16. […] and the vegetable bounty begins. I’ve enjoyed these brownies more than once, and this bread, and this vegetarian cassoulet. And then I made carbonara. […]

  17. le creuset dutch oven
    |

    le creuset dutch oven…

    […]Incredible Vegetable Cassoulet » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  18. Cathy Erway
    |

    Marcie: Oh no! That says apple cider, not cider vinegar in case that’s what you thought! I can’t honestly imagine what this must taste like with a cup of vinegar in it — ouch!!

  19. […] adding more water if necessary, until totally tender. Don’t undercook the beans—as Cathy Erway wrote on her blog a while ago, “there’s little attraction to ‘al dente’ […]

  20. […] I decided to try making vegetarian cassoulet.  One of my favorite cold-weather dishes used to be black bean cassoulet from the Silver Palate cookbook that was filled with black bean goodness, but also cumin and ham hocks and Italian sausage and sherry.  I had a feeling that vegetarian cassoulet was going to need some ingenious ingredients to pack a similar wallop, so I went to scouring the Internets and came up with a few recipes, one of which called itself “Incredible Vegetable Cassoulet“. […]

  21. Randall
    |

    Lovely recipe, but in my experience, beans did not end up completely cooked. Would recommend perhaps cooking them for 45-60 minutes in pot before adding to other ingredients, and/or cooking everything at higher temperature 400, vs. 325.

  22. Rachel
    |

    I’ve made this multiple times over the past couple of years. It is always delicious. Thank you.

  23. LD
    |

    Sure wish you had an easy way to print out the recipe.

  24. […] 16. Casserole – not just an ordinary casserole, this is a cassoulet….. Get the recipe. […]

  25. This chili is great for freezing in individual serving containers and then heating in the
    microwave for a nice hot lunch. It usually affects the small digestive
    tract and it causes the indigestion of food properly. For those who have cardiac and vascular
    issues, gluten in sensitive persons can trigger heart
    attacks, strokes, arteriosclerosis, atherosclerosis, high blood pressure, and other related issues.

  26. cooking for a veg
    |

    Great Recipe! Thanks so much for sharing. It had tons of very rich flavor.

  27. Winona
    |

    I love this recipe. I know you posted it a while ago – but it’s a staple in our home once the temperature drops. Made it today and it was delicious as always!!

    I love your site. You have some of the best ideas and can execute them too! Thanks so much!!

Leave a Reply