Savory Asparagus Pie with Goat Cheese and Creme Fraiche

First of all: Holy heatwave! Bake at your own risk! I was kind of wondering when New York City weather would pull its annual trick of mutating overnight into a festering hotbox of city smog, in turn whipping us into hapless victims of stench. I’m still racking my brain for that clean water-saving alternative to showering twice or thrice daily.

In the meantime, I can recommend a good way to spend a sultry Saturday: Governor’s Island. Even better yet — on one of the days that Michael Arenella and His Dreamland Orchestra will be playing the Jazz Age Lawn Party. This weekend marked the first two days of the annual concert (poor band, in their three-piece suits), and later on this September, there’ll be another full weekend. My friends and I were thrilled to learn that this year, in addition to Charleston lessons, vintage auto shows and flapper hat racks, the event would be featuring a pie recipe contest. All aboard the ferry!

fresh, crisp asparagus slices

crème fraîche and chèvre, the not-so-secret ingredients

alternating stalks and pastry for the lattice crust

There are few things that tug my heartstrings as much as the phrase “pie contest.” Not a pie-eating contest (though that memory sends a chill down my spine, too). Not a pie-in-your-face carnival something-or-other. A contest for the best amateur-baked pie is something I feel like I was brought up to do. I just love making pies. Especially surprising, un-ordinary ones. So it was a no-brainer for me to combine this passion with my recent love affair with asparagus.

I skipped the test round and took the risky route of bringing a pie I hadn’t tasted before to the contest. In it, I’d whipped up some crème fraîche with a log of chèvre; added a sprinkle of fresh chives, sauteed onion, a pinch of nutmeg, a squirt of lemon, an egg to bind it together, and folded in sliced fresh asparagus, raw and snappy. On top and bottom I baked a standard buttery pie crust and wove the lattice top with halved asparagus stalks. Somehow, I didn’t feel like this was very risky at all.

Plus, the worst-case scenario at the contest was that my friends and I would have a delicious addition to our already packed picnic basket.

a slice of the spread (front right: Karol’s winning “Ma’s Apple Pie”)


the judges eat, deliberate

Lady Liston, the contest hostess, offers a slice

the judges got the first taste (before even me!)

In the end, the pie contest worked out quite favorably for all: everyone on the island had the opportunity to try a slice of any pie on the table once the judges were finished with them. But for Karol and I, it was a most idyllic day. Of the three awards handed out in the contest, we each won one of them. Karol’s classic but over-achievingly perfect apple pie took the “Mom’s Best” award, and my pie took “Most Original.” The third category was cleverly titled “Hobo’s Choice,” an allusion to some folky saying about a hobo stealing a pie that was cooling on a windowsill because it looked so tempting. That award went to a lemon meringue pie baked by a lady named Alexandra.

announcement time

We all won hats!

the pie winners, sporting new handmade hats

So, if a panel of six or so judges are any assurance, this “original” asparagus pie recipe makes a tasty meal/breakfast/lunch/dinner/dessert(?). And finally, after creeping around in the crowd waiting for pie slices, I finally got to snag a taste of it myself. In a word: Yum. I wish asparagus season never had to end.

Savory Asparagus Pie
(makes one 9″ pie)

for the filling:
1 large bunch asparagus, ends trimmed; reserve 4 good-looking long stalks and chop the rest to 1/2″ bias-cut slices
1 medium onion, chopped
8 oz. crème fraîche
3.5 oz. chèvre goat cheese
1 egg
1 tablespoon chopped fresh chives
2 teaspoons lemon juice
3/4 teaspoon salt
1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
1/8 teaspoon freshly ground nutmeg
1 tablespoon butter

for the crust:
10 tablespoons cold unsalted butter, cut to cubes
1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
1 tablespoon cold water
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon sugar

Make the crust: Combine the flour, sugar and salt. Cut in butter with a pastry cutter (or pulse in a food processor) until mixture resembles fine crumbs with the butter chunks no larger than a pea. Add a little bit of the cold water at a time until mixture just clumps together in a ball. Shape dough with your hands into one large ball and another ball about 1/4 its size. Cover with plastic and chill for 30 minutes (or up to overnight).

Heat a heavy-bottomed pan with 1 tablespoon of butter on very low heat. Add the chopped onions, and let sweat for about 10 minutes, stirring occasionally to make sure they don’t brown. Once onions are translucent and just slightly caramelized, remove from heat and let cool. In a large bowl, combine the creme fraiche and chevre. Mix with a spatula to combine. Add the egg, and whisk mixture until fully blended. Add salt, pepper, nutmeg, chives and lemon juice. Add the chopped asparagus slices and the cooled onions and mix with spatula.

Roll out the large ball of chilled dough on a lightly floured surface, or on waxed/parchment paper. Transfer to the bottom of a greased 9″ pie pan. (If not using this immediately, cover with plastic wrap and chill in the refrigerator while you prepare the rest of the ingredients.)

Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Roll the smaller ball of dough into a long, thin oval. Slice it into 6-8 strips for the lattice crust (can be any width you desire!). Slice the reserved good-looking asparagus stalks carefully into halves, lengthwise. Pour the asparagus filling into the pan with the bottom pie crust and smooth top with a spatula. Place one asparagus stalk lengthwise down the center. Lay a pastry strip down the center perpendicular to the asparagus. Lay another two asparagus stalks (alternating between the blunt end and the flower tip side by side) to the right and left of the pastry strip. Lay two pastry strips to the top and bottom of the asparagus stalks, gently tucking the middle part of the strip underneath the middle asparagus stalk to create a basketweave. Continue weaving in this manner until you reach the ends of the pie. Arrange any leftover pastry along the top of the pie’s edge and distribute pieces until the pastry edge is fairly even in bulk all around and well-integrated. Crimp or pinch edges in whichever manner you prefer. Brush top of pie with milk or egg wash (optional), and bake for about 40-45 minutes, or until top is just lightly browned. Let cool at least 10 minutes before serving.

Cost Calculator
(for 1 pie, about 8 servings)

1 bunch asparagus: $4.00
8 oz. crème fraîche: $3.49
3.5 oz. chèvre: $3.99
1 egg: $0.28
11 tablespoons butter: $1.38
1 onion: $0.25
1 tablespoon chives (from windowsill plant): $0.20
2 teaspoons lemon juice: $0.15
1 3/4 cups flour: $0.65
salt, pepper, nutmeg, sugar: $0.15

Total: $14.69

Health Factor


Eight brownie points: This pie is not light on cholesterol (nor is it, as you can see, on your wallet). But, when you’re trying to impress, these things are pushed to the side, no? Plus, it’s far from a total wash, nutritionally — it’s asparagus!

Green Factor


Seven maple leaves: Although I’ve been itching to try some of the goat cheese at the Greenmarket, they’re only open Saturdays, and I needed to make this pie on Friday. So I got some chevre and creme fraiche at Trader Joe’s. (I didn’t read the packages thoroughly, so I can’t say much to their environmental/animal friendliness.) Asparagus from the Greenmarket, has been in almost constant supply in my crisper for a while, and the onion and chive plant both came from the same source.

22 Responses

  1. Sarah
    |

    Beauteous! But I think turning on the oven might kill me. I am a constant sweat ball. Make it stop!!!!

  2. dave
    |

    Congrats on the award & on the hat. A really unique recipe, and beautifully executed from the looks of it. You’ve made my pie from thursday’s blogger dinner look like such an all-thumbs concoction. Besides making a beautiful lattice, weaving in the asparagus stalks was genius! Nice job!

  3. Karol
    |

    we did it!

  4. Amanda
    |

    nicely done! I’ve never baked a savory pie, but your “Award” winning one might be my first.

  5. Mel
    |

    Thats awesome! Congrats! Also, totally jealous over those hats…

  6. Erynn
    |

    Congrats! I am impressed with your bravery, I had a pie all ready to go but I couldn’t convince my crew (or myself really) to leave our block in the heat. We ended up taking a bath in cold water with all of our clothes on.

    Looks like it was a fun even, though! And you’re pie would have kicked my pie’s ass.

  7. Julia
    |

    congrats, what a great idea, and it looks beautiful! i’ve never made pie, i’m scared of it. good thinking to make this on friday before the heat wave took over…i cooked all morning in the heat on saturday and ugh – my kitchen was a sauna!

  8. Yvo
    |

    I can’t say anything about pie, though it sounds delicious… but about how to not shower 3-4 times a day (and not blast the AC and not leave the house)… washcloths? I was going to suggest wipes, but since they’re disposable, not really environmentally friendly. I do carry face wipes with me though in this weather :)

  9. michelle @ TNS
    |

    i love the latticework! i’m totally stealing that and passing it off as my own.

    the stench of the city as i walked down 31st street this morning was insane.

  10. EB
    |

    The most perfect brunch recipe ever? Me thinks so.

  11. Joanna
    |

    Oh my gosh, what a beautiful pie!! I’ve been hoarding greenmarket asparagus as well, and I would consider making this, but I don’t have an air conditioner in the kitchen and with the oven on I just might die of heat stroke. Maybe I could leave it on the counter and just let it roast in the ambient heat… :) Congrats on your pie win!

  12. erin
    |

    I was wondering if that was you!! I was at the picnic Saturday and heard the asparagus pie by Cathy win most original! Congrats. What a great picnic.

  13. Johnna Knows Good Food
    |

    This looks really tasty and isn’t hard to make, good pick;-)

  14. alexandra
    |

    This is Alexandra of Lemon Meringue Pie fame. I recognized you in a picture on Grub Street today and found my way to your site. Congratulations on your pie win and great work on the food front.

    Love the asparagus pie process shots…..I have posted my own on picasa:
    http://picasaweb.google.com/alexandra.pulver/PIECOMPETITION

  15. SMDNY
    |

    Love how the color of the asparagus – the purple tips are gorgeous! Thanks for posting another great recipe and congrats on your prize.

  16. We Are Never Full
    |

    what a great site! some great ideas for me to participate in in my own city! this asparagus pie looks so summery and delicious. I’d love to sprinkle some almonds on the top. mmmmm.

  17. Lynne Miles
    |

    I made this pie when friends came round for dinner the other night. It was heavenly, even though I couldn’t find fresh chives and forgot the squirt of lemon juice. Served it with a salad leaves, avocado and roasted tomatoes. My guests loved it. This is one of those recipes I’m going to wheel out over and over!

  18. […] that you’ve concocted/tried over the past few years has surprised you? In a good way? My savory asparagus pie first surprised me because it came out really well; secondly, it’s the dish that the most […]

  19. Dave
    |

    This is a fantastic vegetable pie! I’ve made this many times for family special dinners and it always steps up to the plate to impress! It looks great, tastes superb and is totally fresh and unique! The creme fraiche is very difficult to find, so I always end up making my own: 1 cup whipping cream warmed to 105 deg, then add 1 tbl. buttermilk. Let it sit in a warm place overnight to thicken, then stick it in the fridge until you’re ready to make the pie.
    Thanks for creating this pie! I’m sick of boiled peas as a vegetable dish!!!

  20. E. Foley
    |

    I made this tonight and it was delicious! My boyfriend especially loved it. I couldn’t find creme fraiche, so I subbed in sour cream instead. Next time I make this, I think I’m going to use cilantro instead of chives. Cilantro, goat cheese, and asparagus are VERY tasty together.

    Picture: http://twitpic.com/1napun

  21. Jess
    |

    This is delicious! Made my own creme fraiche as we live in a small town & I didn’t have access to the real thing. I cannot wait to serve this at my next brunch! Thanks for a fabulous savory pie!

  22. Favorite Fall Recipes -
    |

    […] Asparagus Pie […]

Leave a Reply