Savory Corn Pudding, part of my Local Grill-Off entry

It’s the kind of cook-off that was my dream come true: the emphasis? Local food. The dish’s requirements? Nothing, aside from being local. The judges? Three established food writers whom I admire. The fundraiser’s cause? Slow Food NYC. The location? The sandy Water Taxi Beach in Long Island City, where I’d spread out my toes shoeless on several occasions. So maybe not everything turned out to be really dreamlike: it was raining all day, at some points more furiously than others. But I couldn’t have had a better time, as it was, after all, a feast of local food fun. And to top it off, my Grill-Off dish took second place.

The most amazing part of the night may have been just moments after receiving that award. I was handed a bag of prizes that included cookbooks donated from Martha Stewart Omnimedia, and a gift a certificate to 1 Dominick, the newly established sister wine bar of Jimmy’s No. 43 (who was at the event, grilling up sausages from Flying Pigs Farm). One of these books was the latest favorite of grill-off judge Lucinda Scala Quinn’s (of Everyday Food), I had been told. When I pulled it out of the bag I immediately felt a familiar weight. It was the same cookbook I’d been ogling over the past few weeks, and actually, had inspired one of the main components of my grill-off dish.

It’s called Seven Fires: Grilling the Argentine Way by Francis Mallman, but its rich prose and vivid photos tell so much more than that. With the help of co-writer Peter Kaminsky, the author articulately dispels his sturdy opinions on the art of grilling, flavors and food in general (such as the captivating taste of burntness). After receiving a copy of the book, it’s been on my nightstand, couch and I’m ashamed to say it, bathroom towel rack ever since. I took it up to the roof with a cool drink one sunny afternoon, a few days before the cook-off. There I noticed a recipe in the appetizers chapter for “Humita,” or savory corn pudding.

smoking the pork belly

I had been in intense quandary as to what to do for my dish. A few things I knew for sure: I wanted to cure and smoke bacon, to cut into squares. To offset the fat, why not fold them in crisp lettuce wraps? There would have to be something to tie it all together, though. It seems like the newest offerings of the season at market stands are what attracts people most, like the “New in Hardcover” table at bookstores. When something’s just in, everyone suddenly remembers how much they love it. (Sour cherries? That was so two weeks ago.) This was just beginning to happen with corn on the cob. It’s usually later in the summer that we see it the most, but corn had been trickling in discreetly over the past week or so. It’s also a quintessential vegetable for grilling. So my bacon lettuce wraps would feature corn two ways, as shucked kernels of Taiwanese glazed, grilled corn, atop a small mound of savory corn pudding.

It was a simple recipe for the humita in Seven Fires, consisting of fresh, sweet corn, milk, butter, onion and lots of fresh basil. While softening the onions, I added a few small cubano peppers and some just-ripe, black heirloom tomatoes before stirring in the corn kernels for a little more depth. An assortment of garden herbs like chives and oregano accompanied the basil, and I gave it plenty squeezes of lime. The result was a mild, tangy and fresh-tasting “pudding.” I also couldn’t get the mixture to thicken the way I wanted it to, so some fine yellow cornmeal stirred in solved that problem.

edible marigolds

The final assembled lettuce wrap had a slice of black plum (also just in season) on the corn pudding, a squeeze of chile vinaigrette, and edible flora: marigold buds and nasturtiums. These edible flowers are not only irresistibly pretty but they have unique, assertive flavors all their own. The crimson nasturtiums are peppery and a bit garlicky, while the marigolds are more floral and sweet-tasting. Yes, you can really eat them, I found myself saying to many folks. It doesn’t just stop at squash blossoms! And you can find them at market stands this time of the year — I’m pretty sure Windfall Farms always has an assortment of floral garni. (Mine, however, came from Eagle Street Rooftop Farm as well as a friend’s rooftop garden.)

the bacon and corn pudding lettuce wrap (photo by Keith Wagstaff)

I needed to be pulled back to earth when, about an hour before the grill-off was to begin, I decided that I needed to make a fresh herb pesto as a final touch (no). Even still, this has got to be the most frou-frou thing I’ve ever conceived of, but I’m not holding regrets. There was some pretty high standards from the other contestants, also. Cook-off pros Nick Suarez and Theo Peck (who are planning their next cook-off, the cheese experiment, as we speak) teamed up with a bruschetta of fava bean pesto topped with jerk-inspired bacon and fried shallot rings. A team led by Borough Hall Greenmarket manager Dave Sherman made chunky cubed meat and veggie grilled shishkabobs. Jonathan (J.J.) Proville slathered corn on the cob with a sauce made with ham hocks.

There were only three awards our judges could hand out that night: first, second and third places. Pooling their thoughts, expert foodies Josh Ozersky (of The Feedbag), Rachel Wharton (of Edible Brooklyn and Edible Manhattan) and Lucinda Scala Quinn decided on:

3rd Place: Noah Berland, with a dry-aged steak from Marlow & Daughters served with blanched fresh corn

2nd Place: Cathy Erway(!), with the bacon lettuce wraps with corn pudding

1st Place: Doug Keiles, with a house-cured bacon and braised bok choy

As you can see, a couple other folks had corn and bacon on the mind. But Doug’s bacon was really the star — he’s a pro, and has been grilling with his team, the Ribs Within, for passion and friendly competition for some time now. Way to show us! And yes, Noah B. is on a serious winning streak with cook-offs, and refuses to stop.

Because the event was all about local food, each contestant stepped up to the mic to introduce their dish and tell which farms they got their ingredients from. So, aside from said rooftop farms for the flowers, my corn was from Maxwell’s Farm, via Union Square Greenmarket. Black plums were from Red Jacket Orchards. The pastured, all-natural pork belly, from Mountain View Farm. Basis Farm to Chef is the thoughtful provider who’d hooked me up with their meat, a business that does exactly what its name sounds like — facilitate access to farm-fresh food for chefs. Collecting all that lettuce was an interesting feat. When the Williamsburg Paisley Farm CSA drop-off location found itself with bushels of leftover romaine, I was in the right place and time to take as many as I could hang on my handlebars home. (The CSA chapter has since figured out a way to donate leftover produce to City Harvest, but people foregoing their lettuces hadn’t been a big problem until then.) Then, I scored another hoard of romaine from Garden of Eve farm’s post-market day stash. When the scavenging was complete, I had around sixteen heads. Freeganism!

Savory Corn Pudding (recipe adapted from Francis Mallman’s Seven Fires, Grilling the Argentine Way)

makes about 6 servings

8 ears fresh corn, shucked
3/4 cup whole milk
1/2 cup heavy cream (or substitute with milk, to be healthier)
2 tablespoons butter
1 tablespoon olive oil
4 medium shallots, finely chopped
1 ripe tomato, chopped
1 small cubano or jalapeno pepper, seeded and finely chopped
1 cup fresh basil, slivered
2-3 tablespoons fresh lime juice
2 tablespoons fine yellow cornmeal
salt and pepper to taste
1-2 teaspoons red pepper flakes (optional)
1 tablespoon fresh chives (optional)
1-2 teaspoons fresh oregano, finely chopped (optional)

Melt butter in a heavy-bottomed saucepan and cook the shallots over medium-low, stirring occasionally, until translucent and softened, about 6 minutes. Add the pepper and tomato and continue cooking another 2-3 minutes.

Meanwhile, cut the kernels from the fresh corn directly into a bowl (to prevent them from falling all over the counter), catching any juices. Run the back of your knife across the shorn cob to draw any more juices. Add the corn to the saucepan and stir another 2-3 minutes. Add 1/4 cup of the milk and cook, stirring, until absorbed. Repeat with another 1/4 cup of milk, and the next. Add the cream, and season with salt, pepper, red pepper. If mixture is still very thin, add one tablespoon of the cornmeal at a time until it has reached a desired pudding-like consistency. Add the lime juice, basil, olive oil and optional herbs and serve.

Cost Calculator
(for 6 servings)

8 ears corn (at 3/$2 or $0.75 each): $5.50
1 tomato (at $4/lb): $1.25
1 small cubano pepper: $0.40
4 shallots (from CSA share): $0.50
3/4 cup milk: $1.00
1/2 cup heavy cream: $1.00
1 cup basil: $0.50
2 tablespoons butter: $0.40
2 limes: $0.25
olive oil, salt, pepper, red pepper, optional herbs from a home garden: $1.00

Total: $11.80

16 Responses

  1. Liv

    not even a corn fan, but that looks amazing.

  2. Nora

    I realize now this was deceptively simple. I didn’t clock the two types of corn. Maybe because I was shoveling it in my cornhole as fast as I could!

  3. Alejandra

    That looks delicious! I’m absolutely going to give that corn pudding a try.

  4. […] that our friend Cathy Erway (above) just put up on Not Eating Out in New York. It’s the savory corn pudding from her bacon and corn pudding lettuce wraps that won second place to Doug Keiles’ […]

  5. Heather

    God, you’re amazing! So sorry I missed out on this.

  6. Midge

    YES!!! You won! I have been waiting to see if you won! Congrats. This pudding sounds amazing. I will be trying it out very soon.

  7. Martha

    I’m so happy that I got to eat this, my dad used to make corn pudding and I had totally forgotten about how much I loved it until you brought it back into my life! Thank you!

  8. Sarah

    Thanks so much for always posting events like this on here. I can’t usually make them with my work schedule but was so happy to make it to this! Had a great time and really loved your entry.

  9. Morta Di Fame

    Congrats girl! You should be very proud of yourself. I wanted to be there so bad. Sounds like it was a great time. Keep up the great work!

  10. EMC

    Congratulations!! I love the vibrant colors of the dished out product–fantastic!

  11. Deborah Dowd

    I love corn pudding and this looks really delicious!

  12. Paul

    Cathy, Congratulations. Question, the version you served, did it have all of, or any of, the optional ingredients?

  13. Donna

    congratulations on your win!

    I just made this using some leftover ears of grilled corn (and a few substitutions based on what I got from our local farm market- 2 hot cherry peppers, scallions instead of shallots) and it is DELICIOUS!!

    Thank you for the recipe!!!

  14. Scott V. Smallwood

    Hola,I ran across this blog a few days ago and I must say that I have recieved some good points so far.I was just wonderin if you could put some more info about the right way to get slim.

  15. Related information…

    Here’s some more information about the issue…

  16. Get a Free Roof Replacement in 1 Day!…

    […]Savory Corn Pudding, part of my Local Grill-Off entry » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

Leave a Reply