The Brooklyn Beer Experiment: Success!

posted in: Cook-Offs, Events | 16

So we all knew that Brooklyn knows how to cook… off. But what of home beer brewing? Turns out that these are some mean streets for that trade, too. And we wouldn’t have known it if it hadn’t been for the Brooklyn Beer Experiment, the brainchild of two of my favorite cook-off fanatics, Nick and Theo. Joining forces, these once-rivals from many a local cook-off (just look at their resumes) decided to host a joint beer and food competition. Unlike the East New York Farms’ benefit “Chew ‘n Brew” of last fall, in which teams had to cook small plates and brew beer both, the Beer Experiment paired beer with food in two ways: hold a cook-off for food that’s cooked or flavored somehow with beer, and hold a beer-off for amateur home brewers under the same roof. The result is what looks to be an enduring annual event.

The response to the event alone is reason enough. To keep the lines under control at the Bell House, the Gowanus performance space where the cook-off was held, tickets were sold in advance — and they sold out. Food and beer contestants were asked to make 350 bite or sip-sized portions each, and more than forty of them did so, with flying colors. From chickpea and cauliflower Indian pakora to beer-spiked avocado gazpacho, and hoppy homemade IPAs to refreshing wheat beers, I was blown away by the competition, on both sides of the food-and-beer axes. It’s worth saying now if hasn’t been many times over on this blog, but not only are these home cooks/brewers able to make this stuff, and make it well, but they’re willing to labor over it for hours in order to make 350 servings and haul them to a venue in the name of fun, friendly competition and community. I might add that Nick and Theo announced that they plan to host a Cheese Experiment next, among other experiments, and from all the DIY cheese-making in the borough, I can already smell a stench of brilliance.

the judges sat onstage to sip and taste

cook-off contestant turned co-host Nick Suarez

each home brewer brought five gallons of beer

I’d much rather have been a maker rather than a mere taster at this cook-off. But the Hapa Kitchen‘s barbecue for 250 diners being scheduled the day before the Beer Experiment didn’t enable this to happen (a recap of that food fest coming up shortly). Nor was my palate in quite the right place to taste beer by the time the Experiment began, at 1pm — I was so groggy that I could barely finish the 1-ounce pours each brewer was handing out. I eventually voted for an “Aerosmith”-named ale made by my friend Stephen, in a close race against another friend’s first-ever brewing effort, “Doctor DJ,” both of which went overlooked in the final count (goes to show how much I know about beer-tasting). I also enjoyed Sara Morrison’s “Pocket Full of Sunshine” wheat beer served with a lemon wedge. Sarah was the first-place winner for her tofu empanadas in both the audience and judges’ awards in the Tofu Takedown, and it was a unanimous decision from co-judge Akiko and I. After discovering that she was also a home brewer, Sara was recruited to the Beer Experiment where she was the ONLY chick brewer that day. She ended up winning two awards for her beer, and has become one of my personal heroes. When I asked her, “Is there anything you can’t do?” just after trying her wheat beer, her friend replied without pausing a beat: “No.”

ForkThis‘ mashed potatoes and Guinness gravy were overheard to be the “perfect hangover bite”

there was about an even split of sweet and savory entries

pastrami on rye, please

Squeezing my way along the tables of food entries, I recognized Jonathan Proville, serving a pork-braised pulled shoulder in a bun alongside a homemade honey-drizzled cocktail which he called the “Porkslap” (also the beer he braised his meat in); Noah Berland’s Porter funnel cake was far better than the carnival classic; Pork-Off pros Stephanie and Frann made their own braut and braised it in beer and onions, to serve in homemade miniature buns with a squirt of carbonated Rauschbier cream. I thought the craftsmanship and beer flavor really sang in Kathryn Ballard’s “Beer Puffs” with strawberry rhubarb syrup and Chantilly cream, as well as Lisa Tobin’s “Peach Drunken Cream Cakes.” But my favorite of the beer-y desserts was Rachel Crawford’s buttery “Black and Tan Bread Pudding.” And my favorite savory dish Rachel Graville’s unusual entry of beer-braised beef jerky, fashioned after her father’s recipe, which was peppery, chewy and moist. I never knew I liked beef jerky that much.

The judges brought together to critique the entries were nothing to sneeze at, either. At 4pm, the co-hosts stepped up to the stage to introduce them and announce the winners. For the home brew category, the judges were Samuel Merritt, Tom Price of Brooklyn Brewery, Justin Philips of Beer Table, and John Stanko of Smuttynose. Their favorites were:

3rd Place Judges’ Award for beer: Sara Morrison’s “Pocket Full of Sunshine” wheat beer
2nd Place Judges’ Award for beer:
Brad Hillman’s Golden Pale Ale
1st Place Judges’ Award for beer:
Kayne Konecny’s “Squirrel Tail IPA”

Then, of course, the audience does count. After all the votes were counted, turns out the audience had favored some of the same ones, with a new ultimate victor (once again an IPA):

3rd Place Audience Award for beer: Brad Hilman’s Golden Pale Ale
2nd Place Audience Award for beer:
Sara Morrison’s wheat beer
1st Place Audience Award for beer:
Joshua Knolwton’s “Air Mail IPA”

Theo Peck takes an emcee turn

George Duran addresses the audience

And now we come to the food. The judges for the beer-y food entries included Food Network host George Duran, veteran New York Times food writer Peter Meehan and Owner of Crif Dogs and PDT, Brian Shebairo.

3rd Place Judges’ Award for food: Catherine Cornell’s salty, snacky “Beer Boiled Peanuts”
2nd Place Judges’ Award for food: Bonnie Suarez’s (yes, relation to co-host Nick — that’s his mom!) “You Can Have Your Brew and Eat It, Too” curry chicken salad canapes
1st Place Judges’ Award for food: Alyssa Lees’ “Bleecker Street Bites,” a double offering of beer-braised braut and homemade pickles on toasts, and mini beer-infused sticky toffee puddings. A+ for effort!

So what did the audience think of these judges’ food picks? Unlike in the homebrew category, they completely disagreed! Here’s what the ballots had to say:

3rd Place Audience Award for food: Team Pirates’ Booty’s “Righteous Burn” beer-braised pork on corn chips
2nd Place Audience Award for food: Rachel Crawford‘s “Black & Tan Bread Pudding with Boozy Whipped Cream” (at her station, she gave out little cards with the recipe for it — score!)
1st Place Audience Award for food: Chris Woehrle’s “BRKLYN Braised” short ribs

first-place judges’ award food winner Allysa Lees, with prizes aplenty

first-place audience award food winner, Chris Woehrle

Chris’ entry was one of the first things I ate that day, and I kind of knew it would win the audience prize right away — the short ribs were saucy, and perfectly seasoned, and it was served alongside a lemony potato salad with Weissbier and mustard, and topped with a sprinkle of chives. It was amazing. And he’s shared the recipe!

Big kudos to Nick and Theo for throwing this party, and most of all, all the awesome chefs and home brewers whose delicious stuff went unrecognized in the formal awards. Hope everyone’s hangover is almost gone!

Chris Woehrle’s “BKLYN Braised” Short Ribs

4 lbs beef short ribs
1 pack Nieman Ranch Smoked Bacon
2 large onions (diced)
2 stalks celery  (diced)
1 carrot (diced)
6 whole garlic (whole)
1 tablespoon tomato paste
2 bottles Shlenkerla Urbock (German smoked beer)
1 cup beef stock
1 oz dried organic porcini mushrooms
1 tablespoon brown sugar
3 sprigs thyme
1 clove
kosher salt
freshly cracked black pepper

Preheat oven to 300 degrees. Dice bacon, brown in Dutch oven, and remove with slotted spoon when done. Reserve bacon. Pour out all but about a tablespoon of the rendered bacon fat. (But save it! You can always find an excuse to cook something in bacon fat!).

Salt and pepper ribs, and brown on all sides in remaining bacon fat. When browned, remove ribs and set aside. Add onion, celery, carrot and garlic and pinch of kosher salt – cook until softened. Add tomato paste, stir to coat all vegetables, cook until caramelized. Add reserved bacon, beer, beef stock, porcinis, brown sugar, clove and thyme. Stir to blend, and add ribs to liquid. Cover Dutch oven and cook in oven for 3 hours.

Cost Calculator, Health Factor and Green Factor respectfully omitted for guest recipes

16 Responses

  1. Nola

    What a fantastic event! Great food, great beer, great music and excited, enthusiastic people.
    My group also thought that Chris Woehrle’s entry was hands down the best and we loved his T-shirt!
    How generous of him to extend his winning recipe and I can’t wait to try it myself and wow my guests.
    We need more events like this!!

  2. Naomid

    Oh I dreamed all last month about entering this, but didn’t have the dedication to develop my recipes. I was either gonna make gauzpacho flavored with light beer and beer flat bread crouton or rootbeer & beer candy.

  3. sara

    thanks for the great rundown cathy! I have to say, hearing such kind words from you is especially nice to hear since you are the one who inspired my friends and I to cook more!

  4. […] by admin on June 8, 2009 But what of home beer brewing ? Turns out that these are some mean streets for that trade, too. And we wouldn’t have known it if it hadn’t been for the Brooklyn Beer Experiment, the brainchild of two of my favorite cook-off fanatics, … The rest is here: Not Eating Out in New York » The Brooklyn Beer Experiment: Success! […]

  5. […] have hit the blogosphere — first, on the indie side of things, Not Eating Out in New York has a good recap of the Brooklyn Beer Experiment, where, according to the Experiment’s site, surprise judge […]

  6. Liv

    It sounds like it was super bubbly fun! I was sorry to miss the barbecue on Saturday; I look forward to reading the recap!

  7. ruth

    what about the beeramisu? that was my favorite

  8. samuel merritt

    Great wrap up guys. It was a super event and I was honored to judge the beers, some of which were outstanding. Cheers!

  9. samuel merritt

    Great wrap up. It was a super event and I was honored to judge the beers, some of which were outstanding. Cheers!

  10. Dawn Smith

    What a great event, food, beer etc….i love it.

  11. Nice Site. Keep up the good work.

  12. seth

    Here’s our recap of TODAY! Nice meeting you!

  13. […] is a second-time Food Experiment winner (her beer-soaked chicken salad canape took an award at the Beer Experiment). She also happens to be co-host Nick Suarez’s mother. Food competition fanaticism must run […]

  14. Hisako Coiro

    It is my opinion diferrent because my family use another company.It’s relaxed and i love it’s very much.But next screwdriver I will consider this screwdriver stuffs that you just present.Thank!!!

Leave a Reply