Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

Two winters ago, I bought myself an ice cream maker. It cost $50. It has a bowl that needs to stay in the freezer overnight before attempting to use it (trust me, I’ve tried without), and it has a plastic insert that churns the cream into ice cream when the electric motor rotates the bowl around and around. It’s a simple machine, and it’s pretty cheap. And I honestly don’t know why everyone who likes ice cream doesn’t get one!

I had a honeymoon period with this thing during the first year or so of owning it. Not to rehash too much for anyone who was there and read those posts, but there were ice creams with root vegetables, liquors, fresh coffee, basil and mint. Tangy frozen yogurts and fruity sorbets. Not blogged about were plenty of batches of good old vanilla bean, chocolate, Melissa Clark’s strawberry sour cream and brown sugar ice cream. There was a string of green tea, Earl Grey and Chai ice cream making. Then, I turned my attention to newer kitchen toys like the pasta crank while leaving the ice cream maker on the dust-coated cabinet top. But in that heat of passion, I never thought to try one of the most delicious flavor combinations known to mankind with it: peanut butter and chocolate.

Then, over the holidays, a happenstance binge with a bag of mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups left out on the office kitchen counter triggered my lust for that delightful combo in frosty form.

I’m a fan of natural peanut butter, which doesn’t have the emulsifying agents that keep the oils from naturally separating from the solids. This might sound like a problem, a layer of peanut oil on top when you open the jar. But once you stir it, and refrigerate it, they stay where they’re supposed to be — mixed in! I prefer natural simply because most brands that sell it tend to use less sugar than the brand names I grew up with (Skippy, Jiff and Peter Pan), and it seems to have a more prominent roasted peanut taste. I usually get Trader Joe’s natural peanut butter since it’s so cheap, but recently bought a jar of Smucker’s and am loving the rich flavor and slightly grainy texture of the creamy version. (Making peanut butter — now that might just be the next DIY quest!)

peanut butter gets whisked into the egg yolks and sugar

and the heated cream and milk tempers the custard

There really is nothing else to peanut butter-flavored ice cream than adding some peanut butter to your favorite ice cream base. Mine incorporates a few egg yolks, a lighter touch of sugar than normally suggested, and in this case, I used light brown sugar which I thought would go nicely with the peanut butter. Dark chocolate chips, or rather, chunks and shaved bits from a nice bar of it, went into the ice cream maker during the last churn or so to provide the classic chocolately component. I like getting a surprisingly big chunk of this in a bite and having my mouth temporarily consumed with potent dark chocolate.

chopped chocolate chunks, not chips

There is another legendary flavor duo, at least for ice cream, that I haven’t dabbled with yet. It’s butter pecan. I love this flavor and will probably try it out sometime soon, maybe roasting the pecans in a caramely crust first. Also, this month only Ben & Jerry’s is renaming the flavor “Yes Pecan,” describing it as “Amber waves of buttery ice cream with roasted non-partisan pecans.” And they’re donating proceeds from every scoop of it sold in its stores to the Common Cause advocacy nonprofit. Inspirational? In more ways than one.

Lastly, in case anyone was wondering, the plate beneath the ice cream bowl in the top photo is the Curious George plate of my pantry — for some reason, peanut butter and Curious George just seemed to go together.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
(makes about 1 quart)

1 1/4 cups whole milk
1 3/4 cups heavy cream
3 egg yolks
1/2 cup peanut butter
2/3 cup light brown sugar
2 oz. chocolate (I like 60% cacao dark), chopped into chunks

Beat sugar and egg yolks well until fluffy and pale yellow in color. Gradually beat in the peanut butter until smoothly incorporated. Meanwhile, heat the milk and cream in a medium-large saucepan until it just begins to boil. Turn off heat.

While whisking the peanut butter, egg yolk and sugar mixture rapidly, pour in a spoonful of the hot milk mixture. Add another spoonful while whisking, and another (this will cook the yolks, or temper them, evenly). Once you’ve added about half a cup of the hot milk while whisking, transfer it into the saucepan with the rest of the hot milk and cream. Cook, stirring, over medium-low heat. Once custard is just thick enough to coat the back of a spoon (about 6-8 minutes), remove from heat. Let cool, and refrigerate at least 4 hours (or overnight) to completely chill it before putting it into the ice cream maker. Follow your ice cream maker’s instructions to make ice cream, and in the last minute of churning, add the chocolate chunks. Transfer to an airtight container and freeze 2 hours to let it “ripen”; alternately, it can be served immediately at a softer texture.

Cost Calculator
(for 1 quart)

1 1/4 cups cream (at $2.50/pint): $1.56
1 3/4 cups whole milk (at $2.29/quart): $0.60
3 egg yolks (at $3/dozen): $0.38
2/3 cup sugar: $0.25
2 oz. dark chocolate (at $2.99/4 oz. bar): $1.50
1/2 cup peanut butter (at $3.09/16 oz. jar): $0.76

Total: $5.05

[Health Factor: 9 brownie points]

Nine brownie points: Eat in moderation, and it’s best to consult your hungerness factor before each use. If you could eat a horse, I might recommend doing that over opening a tub of this peanutty, buttery, chocolately, creamy goodness. America’s peanut farmers have been doing much in the way of marketing in the last decade, as if we didn’t know nuts had protein. There are many surprising health benefits to peanut butter, but just keep in mind that this food is mostly a fat.

[Green Factor: 5 maples leaves]

Five maple leaves: There isn’t much to say for the ice cream ingredients that hasn’t already been said before: the dairy and eggs can be bought locally from farms with environment and animal-friendly values, so that’s always the best start. Organic peanut butter and chocolate are common creatures of the supermarket these days, and though I didn’t have either of these this time around, these options as well as fair trade chocolate are widely available.

24 Responses

  1. Erin C

    I’ve heard from other people that they have had to freeze the container before using. I’ve always wanted to get an ice cream maker, but I have one of those side by side freezer/refrigerators, and I know for a fact it wouldn’t fit in there. Is this a pretty common consideration with ice cream makers?

  2. Angeline

    Have you ever tried filling the bucket with ice maybe 30 minutes before you want to use it the way they ice glasses at bars? Would that work?

  3. Nick

    If you feel like indulging, pay the $300 for the Cuisinart ICE-50. It has the freezing unit within, so there is no pre-freezing anything. Just put the ingredients in and turn it on. Easy as 1,2,3. I sound like an infomercial, but the ice cream is really top-notch.

  4. Teresa

    I keep my container in the freezer all the time (even though I haven’t used my ice cream maker in a couple months). The freezer is small, but I don’t keep a lot in there anyway — and then I can make ice cream without having to worry if the container is frozen enough.

  5. EB

    I keep my bowl in the freezer 24/7. I have a 3/4 size fridge so I’ve started stashing the frozen peas in there to save space.

  6. cathy

    Hi Erin C: Well, as long as you can shove some things aside or place frozen stuff inside the bowl the night before you want to make the ice cream, you should be set!
    Angeline: YES, I have tried sneaky time-cutting methods just like that once, and it didn’t work! Cream just kept churning, not freezing…

  7. Dory

    Making peanut butter is super-easy and very satisfying. I did it all summer, with kids, and it was splendid (

  8. HS

    The canister is not very big, and easily fits in almost any freezer. I don’t think putting ice in it would help at all because it’s not the temperature of the surface that matters, but the temperature all the way through. This is due to how long it takes for the ice cream to churn. If only the outside is cold, it will warm up very quickly.

  9. beth

    always force yourself to let the custard sit in the fridge over night- i had too many soupy batches from trying to convince myself the custard was cool enough from sitting in an ice bath you’ll have to wait a full 24 hours for the canister to re-freeze too

  10. Ashley

    this looks fantastic! Can’t wait to try it out 🙂

  11. pfan

    We have the kitchen-aid freezer bowl, and if you already have a kitchen-aid it saves some storage space not to get a separate dedicated ice cream maker. I’ve made sorbet, frozen yogurt, and sorbet in it, and while it’s not perfect it does work pretty darn well.

    Icing the sleeve with the refrigerant would not be nearly enough to make ice cream. When I know I’m going to use it, I give it 24 hours in the freezer at the absolutely coldest setting. At that point it gets the ice cream set in less than the 20 minutes specified in recipes I’ve seen.

    Giving the custard a day to chill in the fridge before making the ice cream is a definite help, and letting it set up in the freezer after it’s processed also is a very good thing for “real” ice cream texture.

    A maker with included refrigerant would clearly be the absolute best option, but it’s expensive and bulky, and how much do most of us actually make ice cream really?

  12. Heartburn Home Remedy

    This topic is quite trendy on the Internet at the moment. What do you pay the most attention to when choosing what to write about?

  13. […] or cream if carrots are steeped in it, which will lend liquid, or to lessen it if something like peanut butter is going in). I’m not sure when it all came together, there was no Eureka moment or stroke of […]

  14. Katie

    YUM!! There’s a place in Andersonville here in Chicago that has “Fat Elvis” ice cream, which is banana ice cream with peanut butter swirls and chocolate chunks. A must for any peanut-butter chocolate lover. Something you might have to try in the good-ol’ ice cream maker.

    And why are your eggs so expensive? Are you buying regular eggs or cage-free organic types? (’cause then I would understand the price increase)

  15. Lori

    Here is a great place to find a ice cream maker at

  16. ice machines

    ice machines…

    […]Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Ice Cream » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  17. LED Controller

    the first time to be here,great post,like your writing style

  18. Baked Recipes

    Baked Recipes…

    […]Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Ice Cream » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  19. zak ice cream machines reviews…

    […]Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Ice Cream » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  20. […] Image 1, Image 2, Image 3, Image 4, Image 5, Image 6 […]

  21. Lisa

    I just saw this and have to say that I have the custard on the stove thickening, chocolate chopped, and ice cream maker ready to go on the counter.

  22. Look there for more:

    […]you make blogging glance[…]

Leave a Reply