Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough-Topped Cupcakes

posted in: Desserts, Recipes | 30

Warning: This product contains raw egg.

It has, however, been tested in the Brooklyn kitchen of Not Eating Out in New York, and ingested at a gathering of cupcake enthusiasts in Manhattan, held by the blog Cupcakes Take the Cake. It was deemed delicious by all, and no subsequent injuries were suffered that I am aware of.

Despite the slight risk of Salmonella and other food-bourne illnesses, cookie dough has probably been eaten by every American since the raw dough craze took off in the early 1990’s — in ice creams, refrigerated tubes, and straight from the mixing bowl. Here it’s transplanted on a vanilla cupcake as a frosting substitute. When I brought these to a cupcake social hosted by Rachel and Nichelle of Cupcakes Take the Cake last week (just something I scraped together on a whim, which I’ll describe further below), I had no idea the reception they would receive. Rachel’s eyes nearly popped out of their sockets when I told her what was on them — no, it’s not chocolate chip cookie dough-flavored frosting, it’s really the raw dough. This is more or less the same reaction that occurred with everyone else at the party once they found out.

Rachel and Nichelle, two-thirds of the bloggers behind Cupcakes Take the Cake

the not-frosting-topped cupcakes

Now, if I have done something with cupcakes that these smart ladies have never seen before, let alone were impressed with, then I could die and go to cupcake heaven happily. But I couldn’t believe how quickly these were all scarfed up! One happy eater even came up to me and said he would bow down if there were room in the place, or something like that. Another commented on how much she liked the fact that the dark chocolate chips I used were such big, boxy chunks. So before I go apply for a US patent, please, go ahead and try making them for your friends next. I’d love to hear how it goes. (Just kidding about the patent.)

I was talking with someone today who remarked on what he thought to be an uncanny correlation between cupcakes/baking and sex writing, particularly female-written. I can’t remember how we came to this observation, but we soon realized that we both sort of were thinking of Rachel, who is also an accomplished erotica writer. My opinion in this debate would place cupcakes more or less along the lines of chocolate, woman’s natural replacement for sex. (Or at least, that’s what the marketers of Dove chocolate would like us to think.) I don’t really have much else to say to this, but it occurred to me that I got the inspiration for these cupcakes one night a couple days before making them. I was in a sort of bum mood, so I broke out the DVD from the red Netflix envelope that had been sitting on my table for the past week, The Diving Bell and the Butterfly, and popped it in. The moment I got myself situated all nice and snug in front of the screen, I popped back up, as if the couch had springs. Cookies. I wanted to bake myself a tray of chocolate chip cookies. I turned the TV around to face the kitchen as I banged around opening cabinet doors, spilling flour and sugar from their sacks, and whipped up a small helping of six cookies, half-listening to the film in French (and not understanding a word). I had to take down the proportions wildly — the recipe on the back of my package of chocolate chips yielded something like 36. Parsing it down to a mere third, I ended up using one-third of a beaten egg. Nevertheless these questionable calculations, the cookies didn’t turn out too bad. Actually, they were the best I’d had in a while, I thought, as I polished off the last of them before the subtitled movie. Then I fell asleep on the couch. Probably drooling chocolate onto it.

Anyway, that’s my little salvation story from chocolate, or cookies, or their subsequent cupcakes, or all three. Or just baking for the sheer need of something sweet and luscious in my night.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough-Topped Cupcakes
(makes 6 cupcakes)

for the basic vanilla cupcakes:
1/2 cup sugar
1/4 cup unsalted butter, softened
1 large egg
3/4 all-purpose flour
a little less than 1 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
1/3 cup milk
pinch of salt

for the cookie dough:
1/2 cup all-purpose flour
1/4 cup unsalted butter, softened
1/4 cup packed brown sugar
1 tablespoon sugar
1/3 of a beaten egg (save the rest for next morning)
1/4 teaspoon vanilla
pinch of salt
1/2 cup or so semi-sweet chocolate chips or chunks

Preheat oven to 375 degrees. In a mixing bowl, beat together the butter, sugar and vanilla for the cupcakes only. Add egg and beat until fully blended and creamy. Combine the flour, baking soda and salt in a separate bowl. Gradually add flour mixture to butter mixture, alternately adding the milk gradually. Divide equally among six cupcake liners in a muffin tray. Bake about 20-25 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center of a cupcake comes out clean. Let cool completely.

Meanwhile, make the cookie dough: Beat together the butter, sugars and vanilla. Add the egg and beat until creamy. Gradually add the flour and salt, and once fully blended and smooth, add the chocolate chips. Cover and chill in the refrigerator at least 15 minutes. Divide dough into 6 equally-sized balls and press with your palms into discs resembling chocolate chip cookies. Press on top of the cooled cupcakes.

Cost Calculator
(for 6 cupcakes)

1 1/4 cups flour: $0.35
1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoon sugar: $0.25
1/4 cup brown sugar: $0.20
1/2 cup (1 stick) butter: $1.00
1 1/3 egg: $0.33
1/3 cup milk: $0.20
3/4 teaspoon vanilla: $0.20
1/2 cup chocolate chips: $1.25
<1 teaspoon baking powder, pinches of salt: $0.10

Total: $3.88

Health Factor

Nine brownie points: Doesn’t it feel oh-so-good to be so bad once in a while? I can’t think of anything redeeming about these cupcakes healthwise, really, unless I wanted to jump in on the antioxidant power of dark chocolate campaign. Health warnings aside, this recipe might actually be a little better for you than a typical vanilla cupcake topped with a typical-sized scoop of typical buttercream frosting — there’s just a little less butter and sugar in the dough. But that’s really not the point, now, is it?

Green Factor

Two maples leaves: I’m drawing a blank here. Sure, my refrigerator is generally stocked with hormone-free, organic or cage-free butter, milk and eggs. Aside from those and other pantry staples, I did nothing to scope out more locally-produced or perhaps fairly traded chocolate, though, so the package I got is some generic Baker’s brand. Another (less desperate?) time, I suppose.

30 Responses

  1. Erin

    Be still my cookie dough loving heart! These look fabulous.

  2. Ganda

    Genius. I wonder if the salmonella averse (or preggers) could skip the egg, since it’s such a small amount and it’s really there to bind and leaven the baked cookie. Perhaps for richness and consistency one could use a little heavy cream instead?

  3. Beth

    How about using pasteurized eggs for the cookie dough?

  4. Alejandra

    What a brilliant idea! I always find that i love the cookie dough even more than the actual cookies. Sometimes I whip myself a batch of them with only the egg whites. Maybe this would work for the frosting? Also like Ganda’s cream suggestion. Can’t wait to try!

  5. Jason

    These were definitely one of my favorites at the meetup. So glad you brought them!

  6. cathy

    Thanks all! Ganda and Beth: You guys are totally right about the egg — I kind of liked using it for authenticity’s sake, but I suppose you don’t need it. I also thought about cooking the cookies ever so slightly before plopping them on top — you know that totally gooey, warm, but mostly raw stage? Hm…

  7. Daisy

    THese look so yummy. I am defiantly going to have to try them. Can’t wait! Thanks for sharing. Daisy~

  8. Deborah

    Raw cookie dough is one of the things I miss the most since becoming pregnant. I’ll be remembering this for after the baby is born, though!

  9. Cathy-wheresmydamnanswer

    That is brilliant!! What a great and unique recipe – I love this one just the way it is and it will be a HUGE hit in my house!! Cheers

  10. Mary

    You can substitute 1 T soy flour + 1/4 c water for an egg in any cookie recipe. No taste difference or difference in the final product that I’ve ever noticed.

  11. maggie

    There must be something about cookies in the air—I spent last week making them and blogging about them too…but to combine cookies and cupcakes—the best of both worlds!

    I bet the pasteurized egg would work fine, or even going without…

  12. Rose

    Omg! Your pictures are my porn!! Those cupcakes look to die for!!!! Oh my…i’ve got to go find my grandmax recipe for choc chip cookie dough immediately!

  13. Kirsten

    Yummy! I think, I will love these cupcakes!

  14. Jaime

    I like your blog. I love the premise. It would be very hard to live around all that amazing food, and still know you have to pay your rent every month. Kudos to you, and may you get LOTS of advertising so you only have to cook everything if you WANT to.

  15. EB

    Ok you’re insane. In the best way, and this is why we love you.

  16. Kali

    I love my pasteurized eggs! I can’t wait to try this recipe.

  17. Mabrie

    These look AMAZING (along with most things on your blog)!
    I would love to site this on my blog…is that ok?

  18. megan

    this is absolutely brilliant. cupcakes + cookie dough = heaven on earth. kudos to you!

  19. […] Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Topped Cupcakes from Not Eating Out in NY Earl Grey Cookies from The Kitchn. […]

  20. Tanya

    I’ve noticed that connection too… and I am both a food blogger/ baker and a sex educator as well.

    My theory is that people who are smart and sensual are naturally attracted to writing, baking and sex.

  21. Andrea

    Yay! just made these – sooo delicious. It was an incredible success. Thanks Cathy!

  22. Baked Goods

    […] Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cupcakes Recipe via Not Eating Out in New York […]

  23. annette

    My kids are going to wonder who’s in the kitchen!
    Thank you for inspiring this chef mama.

  24. Half Baked | Sprout & Pea

    […] I loved the way the gluten-free almond but­ter brown­ies I made had turned out so I decided to turn these into cup­cakes.  I went back and forth with icing top­pings — includ­ing goat cheese frost­ing —  and finally set­tled on cookie dough, a top­ping I had once tried from a recipe on Not Eat­ing Out In NY. […]

  25. Not A New Yorker

    I know this post is quite old, but the cupcakes still look delicious! Not eating dessert out is my biggest temptation…

  26. healthy diets

    healthy diets…

    […]Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough-Topped Cupcakes » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  27. Baked Recipes

    Baked Recipes…

    […]Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough-Topped Cupcakes » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  28. easy cupcake recipe

    Looking for information on Cupcake Recipe Books? Visit my website at http://www.!

  29. garage door repair phoenix

    It’s very trouble-free to find out any topic on web as compared to books, as I found this piece of writing at this web page.

    My blog garage door repair phoenix

  30. Best 4Th of July Independence Day Design template flyers

    […] Download link – 4th of July Flyer design template – This is one of our most popular creative posters – the Independence Day Poster – also known as “military appreciation poster template“. And this time it’s more versatile th…

Leave a Reply