Carrot Walnut Scones

Ever had a really good, juicy carrot? Not the kind that’s all white and dehydrated like your skin in the winter, I mean a plump, bursting balloon of sweetness, with a few wisps of fuzzy roots and wrinkles, maybe, but a thin skin that betrays its more-orange-than-an-orange flesh? Thankfully, I have. And it’ll never be forgotten. Granted, I can eat carrots any way, shape or form: raw, cooked, juiced, shredded or mashed — and yes, wispy and dry as my skin right now, too. But it’s a whole other level of enjoyment when the ingredient is at its prime.

So when I saw carrots that looked really good at the Greenmarket, I did the only sensible thing and stocked up like a lunatic. Who cares if there’d be only carrots to eat that week? Not too many things looked particularly fetching that day anyway. This is one of the reasons why it usually makes more sense to do your menu-planning after you shop, especially if you plan to eat locally and seasonally. The time spent “planning ahead” frequently just goes waste. Sure, you might have a sense of what’s available beforehand, but you won’t necessarily know what’s available that’s amazing until you check it out, so dependent on chance and nature this is. That’s it, I’m going on an amazing-only diet.

So these carrots and I had some good times. I roasted a number of them, as triangular chunks in olive oil and sea salt and they turned out better than expected. I made a lot of stock that week, which they went into, and a minestrone-like soup with them, too. I ate them as snacks, skins and all. Then a birthday brunch potluck party was coming up. I had to make something to bring. “I’ll just see what’s at the market that morning,” I told the host, when reserving my place with a plus-dish. It was on the way to his home. But that’s not what I ended up doing, as there was one carrot left.

I was never a huge fan of muffins, which so often seem like a more socially acceptable way to eat extra-large cupcakes in the morning. Scones suit me better, they’re barely sweet and more biscuity. They’re not supposed to knock your socks off with flavor, if you’re wearing any at that hour, just fill you up in a few portable bites. But like with muffins, you can manipulate them to be more healthful, by using whole grain flours or adding fresh fruit, vegetables or nuts to the batter. So I dyed a batch of scone dough orange with the carrot, finely shredded, and added some cinnamon and walnuts as well.

carrots go through a fine grater

half whole wheat flour and all-purpose with baking powder, spices and sugar

And ginger, nutmeg and equal portions of whole wheat flour and all-purpose. The egg was beaten and combined with the carrot, and mixed with the dry ingredients, which had already been cut with butter. Because of all the moisture that the shredded carrots lent the dough, I hardly needed to use any milk, as most recipes include. Give it a splash if you try it out yourself; it can really depend on how juicy your carrot was.

combining the wet and dry ingredients

forming the dough into scones

Once you have a workable dough, forming the scones is really simple. Imagine making a pizza, but not having to deal with yeasty dough that pulls back every time you stretch it, or wanting to make as thin a round sheet as you can possibly make — okay, so it’s not actually like making pizza at all. Which is good. You just pat the dough into a ball, squash it down on a floured surface, and pat it into a wheel about 1 1/2 inches thick. Now, cut the round into quarters, and then wedge-shaped eighths. Sprinkle the surface of the wedges well with sugar, if you want to make them glisten a little. Bake, and let cool. And a halfway healthy breakfast pastry is done — these last pretty well throughout the week.

Carrot Walnut Scones
(makes 8 )

1 cup whole wheat flour
1 cup all-purpose flour
1/3 cup cold unsalted butter, cut into cubes
3 tablespoons sugar, plus more for sprinkling
4 teaspoons baking powder
1 egg
1/4 cup milk
1 medium carrot, finely shredded (about 1/2 cup packed)
1/3 cup or so walnut pieces
1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon ground ginger
1/4 teaspoon nutmeg (optional)
1/4 teaspoon salt

Combine the dry ingredients in a large bowl. Cut in the butter with a pastry cutter or using your fingers until butter pieces are no larger than a pea. Make a well in the center and add the egg and milk. Beat gently with a fork. Add the shredded carrot and continue stirring, scraping down some of the dry ingredients from the sides as you stir. Add the walnuts about halfway into mixing. Stir until all ingredients are incorporated.

Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Pat dough into a ball and turn onto a lightly floured surface. Press down into a round, evenly flat wheel about 1 1/2 inches or so tall. Cut into eighths and sprinkle the wedge-shaped eighths with sugar. Place about an inch apart on a baking sheet and bake for approximately 15 minutes, or until just golden.

Health Factor

Five brownie points: This is still a buttery, traditional breakfast pastry, but it’s not as buttery as can be, and it’s also been given a boost with fresh vegetable vitamins. True, you’re only getting one eighth of a carrot if you eat just one scone, but it’s better than nothing. And whole wheat flour has a host of health benefits over refined, yet is not often found in scones and other stuff like this.

Green Factor

Seven brownie points: I’ll have to scope out some of these locally sourced flours next time I’m at the market, or rather, when my hulking bag of whole wheat flour is out. It’s been exciting to hear that more grains and flours are available from small farms upstate through Cayuga Organics, and if reports are correct, may have that amazing quality over the average versions. The upstate small farm carrots, of course, we know are already there.

11 Responses

  1. dave

    Thanks Cathy — now I’m going to be thinking about those scones ALL DAY!

  2. Joanna

    First, those scones look delicious! Second, I’ve seen the Farmer Ground Flour in stores too, I think at Greene Grape Provisions in Fort Greene. Haven’t tried the flour yet but the polenta is out of this world! It’s coarsely-ground, so it takes a little longer to cook, but the texture and taste are definitely amazing. Makes great cornbread too.

  3. knittingoutloud

    Your recipes just look scrumptious! Cassoulet, bean puree, and now carrot walnut scones. Yum.

  4. Amedy

    I think this will be delicious I love to try it

  5. Emily

    Ok I just made these and all I can say is these are so amazing!!!! And easy!! I was pretty hesistant to make scones since baking and I don’t really get along but I gave this recipe a try and I was so happy with the way they turned out. Thanks so much for sharing this!

  6. Amy

    Noticed you commented about locally sourced flour. Purchase a Nutrimill Wheat Grinder and you will forever be in love!! I buy 50 pounds of wheat in bulk and save sooo much money. I grind spelt, buckwheat, rice, you name it. Love your site. I really want to read your book.

  7. […] might also enjoy these scones: Pistachio and Date Scones recipe at EatMakeRead Carrot Walnut Scones recipe at Not Eating Out in New York Maple Oatmeal Scones recipe at The Way The Cookie Crumbles […]

  8. Rachel

    Any idea what would happen if butter were replaced with olive oil? I want to eat these every day, and the butter is all that’s holding me back…

  9. virgin mobile website

    topic that concentrates on a specific type…

    of people and age. in addition, the material you write should be good and not worthless. you have to make solid points, you have to be updated, and your information should always be right.keywords are the next big thing that you…

  10. […] Wortel Scones Aangepast van Not Eating Out In New York […]

  11. Gail

    I discovered this blog today, in July 2020. I haven’t eaten out in my neck of the plains since February.
    I absolutely LOVE the originality, use of what is fresh and ‘looks best’ at the market. So glad to have discovered this trove of recipes and techniques. The photos are beautiful, and the writing enhances the approach to ingredients and how things come together for a dish. Thank you.

Leave a Reply