Better Tuna Noodle Casserole


I watched Jacques Pepin make a dish on public television that was so appealing for a cold weeknight, a casserole of pasta baked with peas, corn and diced French ham in a simple beschamel with cheese sprinkled on top. He put it in the broiler–one of the most overlooked part of your kitchen, according to Mark Bittman–to brown a warm, cheesy crust on the top, and voila! Gooey and liquid inside, contrasting crisp. Countryish warm fuzzy feelings abound.

It looked so warm and nurturing and simple, something a mother would make. I wish Jacques Pepin would be my mother. Mmm… French pastry.

Using up what I had in my kitchen and substituting what I didn’t, I found myself making a similar recipe to his, only with half a can of white tuna instead of ham. Threw in peas, fresh mushrooms, a chopped scallion, and it was delicate and light, perfect for cold weeknight eating–to mimic one of Jacques’ repetitious expressions, “you know?” Yes, I know.

In the same episode, Jacques also made a simple salad of romaine and radiccio with a dressing made from a spoonful each of salsa and balsamic vinegar, emulsified in a drizzle of olive oil. I chopped up a few olives and a little bit of the juice instead, and it made one tasty romaine salad. No recipe needed.

There was a recipe for a tuna noodle casserole in the first cookbook I ever owned, a cardboard-bound Cooking for Kids by the Klutz Press. I guess I haven’t forgotten the combination–though I believe theirs consisted of tuna, noodles, and a can of cream of mushroom soup. Here’s to a better version.

Better Tuna Noodle Casserole
(makes 3-4 servings)

½ box shaped pasta or egg noodles, cooked
1 Tb butter
1 Tb flour
¼ cup frozen peas, thawed
1/8 cup finely chopped onion
4-5 button mushrooms, sliced
1 scallion, chopped
½ can white tuna
1 cup milk and 1/2 cup heavy cream or sour cream (or 1 1/2 cups milk)
¼ cup grated parmesan
Salt and fresh ground pepper to taste
Handful fresh chopped parsley

Turn on broiler or just turn oven to 500 degrees. Melt butter and sauté onions and mushrooms on medium low heat for a few minutes (until they begin to smell wonderful). Season with salt and pepper. Add flour and stir for a minute. Add milk and stir until it boils and gets bubbly. Add cream if using. Taste for seasoning. Turn off heat, and stir in tuna, peas, scallion, parsley, and a little bit of the parmesan if desired. Fold pasta into mixture and pour into a medium casserole dish. Sprinkle a layer of parmesan on top of casserole and broiler for approximately five minutes, checking that it doesn’t burn. Let cool a minute, and serve.

Cost Calculator
(for 3-4 servings)

½ box shaped pasta: $0.65
1 Tb butter: $0.17
¼ cup frozen peas: $0.20
1/8 cup finely chopped onion: $0.08
4-5 button mushrooms: $0.40
1 scallion: $0.20
½ can white tuna: $0.60
1 cup milk and ¼ cup heavy cream or sour cream (or 1 ¼ cups milk): about $0.75
¼ cup grated parmesan: $0.45
Handful fresh chopped parsley: $0.15
Small amounts of salt, pepper, flour: $0.03

Total: $3.68

Health Factor

Four brownie points – not seeing a whole lot of recipes under five brownie points these past few really cold weeks. There’s cheese, milk, and cream, yes, but it’s not heavy, and the flavors are still fresh and tame–nothing overpowers. The white tuna comes out mild-tasting, and in addition to those precious fishy omega-3 and omega-6 vitamins that’s become all the rage lately, you’ve got a well-balanced meal.

19 Responses

  1. michael

    Listen, you gotta resize those photos. You’re killing me with your 3000×2000 hi-res images all over the place. It takes like 5 minutes to load your page (from here in China).

  2. Yvo

    Mmmmm, yummy. That looks delish. I may give this a go later in the week.

  3. larisa

    Love this posting, love Jacques Pepin and LOVE Tuna Noodle Casserole. Thanks for adding the recipe! Please check out!!

  4. tre

    i made this last night it was a hit! delicious.. thanks for the recipe!!!

  5. Janine

    I made this yesterday and loved it! A lighter version of the ol’ tuna-noodle – totally delcious.

  6. Popcorn

    Mmmm. I have to admit that I love tuna casseroles. I know that is terribly un-hip of me but there it is.

    And I like your photos 🙂

  7. Heather

    This was just a great, homey recipe. I’ve had it on my mind since I first read the post and finally made it tonight. It reminded me of my mom’s tuna casserole, but so SO much better.

    Thanks for the recipe, and – in general – for this website. You’re such an inspiration!

  8. sarah

    Nothing wrong with ur photos, and it helps that they’re big enough to see the food. When I search for recipes I look for two things: Ingredients used and what the food looks like cooked…so don’t change a thing.

  9. Janet

    Why only 1/2 a can of tuna?

  10. Anna

    This was yummy and simple! I have made it twice, the first time this recipe exactly. The second time I used asparagus instead of peas and added panko bread crumbs on the top. It was a great variation!

  11. […] all likelihood this is may be my 1,000th time making Cathy’s “better tuna noodle casserole,” but why fight it?  It’s the best.  I always use 1 cup milk and 1/2 cup sour cream […]

  12. Lynne

    How about some specifics? What size of tuna can are we talking about here? (Kind of important to state this.) And what are the measurements of a “medium” casserole dish??

  13. 18 oyunlar oyna

    18 oyunlar oyna…

    […]Better Tuna Noodle Casserole » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  14. real estate in the philippines

    real estate in the philippines…

    […]Better Tuna Noodle Casserole » Not Eating Out in New York[…]…

  15. […] are followed by a huge sigh from Danny. I truly don’t see why because he found this fantastic recipe and I just can’t imagine how he could think it is anything but delicious. He usually agrees […]

  16. Maria

    This is a great recipe. I really liked it. Thank you.

  17. pro hormones

    pro hormones

    Better Tuna Noodle Casserole » Not Eating Out in New York

  18. Angelina

    I’m sure it’s totally awesome, but you can’t re-invent the wheel. Gimme that good ol’ Tuna Noodle Casserole with Cream of Mushroom soup, any day! It’s what I grew up with, and it’s pure comfort food to me. BTW, I’m a huge proponent of eating healthy, but there are times in our lives in which we need to feed not only our tummies, but also our hearts & souls. Mangia!

  19. Iddy

    pasta comes in different size boxes. Please be more specific on the amount.

Leave a Reply