Carrot Cake Ice Cream with Cream Cheese Sauce

Sometimes, words don’t even come close. Sometimes photos don’t do the trick. Sometimes, like when dealing with something as delicious as this ice cream, there is no proper justice. But I will try.

fresh, crisp Greenmarket carrots ($3/big bag)

It started with this big ‘ol bag of carrots. Last week I got a load of tomatoes at the Greenmarket. This Saturday, I made off like a happy wabbit. My snacking binges have gotten a little out of hand lately, so I thought these easy munchables would provide some buffer between me and the office vending machine. Only, the workweek hadn’t even started by the time I decided to turn the healthy veggies into minions of one of my most decadent desserts.

carrots zip through a grater

brown sugar adds a little density to the flavor’s sweetness

This recipe came out of one of those, I wish someone would do that moments. Make an ice cream fashioned after carrot cake, with chunks of chopped nuts and plump raisins, and top it with a sauce fashioned after cream cheese frosting. Why not? Unlike so many of these moments, this one had been followed by action.

shredded carrot and raisins cook in cream until soft

These knobby, cute little carrots were so juicy and bright after shredding that they immediately seeped into the milk and cream even before it was heated. To soften them to that familiar stage we’re used to seeing in carrot cake, I let them simmer for about half an hour with the milk mixture, along with the raisins. By the time the ice cream was done, I think most of the smaller shreds completely blended in as mush; and the raisins had grown to fat, full balloons that were just breaking apart in the churning process. Only the pecan bits, tossed in at the last few churns, retained their original shape, and add a nice crunch to the cream. Maybe ice cream isn’t one of the most decadent desserts on the planet, but this one sure tasted up there. Something about the way the warm spices of cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger mix with velvety dairy is intoxicatingly good. I could smell it even while beating the spices up with the sugar and egg yolks, a haunting portent of an endless snacking session to come.

sometimes you feel like a nutmeg

I’ve been watching the Olympics a lot lately, like many of you may have been, too. Gymnastics are my favorite. I find great satisfaction in seeing someone complete exactly what they know they’re capable of doing, all in one routine. The thought came over me while I was digging into this carton of ice cream and watching the Games, that here is one instance when everything I know about ice cream making came together perfectly. Beautifully. From letting the custard heat just long enough that it coated the back of a metal spoon, to not letting the ice cream churn too long, so that it turned slightly buttery, but taking it out right at that soft, almost soupy stage and letting it ripen to the right texture in the freezer (which was so not intuitive the first few times I made ice cream). I’d give the consistency of this ice cream’s base a perfect ten. (Although I took too long setting up the photo so it melted too much in the photo at top.) After all, the Olympic ice cream making scoring system can still use perfect tens in my dream world.

The only hurdle next is not eating so much that my stomach turns to complete flab. Nastia has great abs. You can see them through her leotard, that’s how great they are.

a perfect finish

Carrot Cake Ice Cream
(makes about 1 quart)

2 cups whole or 2% milk
1 cup heavy cream
5 egg yolks
1/3 cup white sugar
1/4 cup packed brown sugar
1/2 cup packed shredded carrots
1/4 cup raisins
1/4 cup chopped walnuts or pecans
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
1/8 teaspoon nutmeg
1/8 teaspoon ground ginger

In a small bowl, beat the egg yolks with the sugars and spices until fluffy and the lighter in color. Set aside.

Combine the milk, cream, carrots and raisins in a medium saucepan. Bring mixture just to a boil, then reduce heat to very low. Let simmer, stirring occasionally, for 25 minutes. (Do not let boil.)

While beating the egg yolk mixture, pour in a small spoonful of the hot milk mixture and continue to beat. Repeat process with a larger spoonful, while beating, then repeat again, and again. (This will temper the eggs, so that they don’t cook lumpy.) Next, scoop all the egg yolk mixture into the hot milk mixture. Return heat to medium-low. Cook about 8-10 minutes longer, stirring frequently with a spatula to scrape all corners of the bottom of the pot. Do not let boil. The custard should be just thick enough to coat the back of a spoon, but have no lumps.

Let custard cool completely, then transfer to an airtight container and completely chill in the refrigerator at least 2 hours. Follow your machine’s instructions for churning length. Add the chopped nuts in the last minute of the churning process. Transfer ice cream to an airtight container and freeze for 2 hours to “ripen.” Serve with the cream cheese sauce (recipe below).

Cream Cheese Sauce
(makes about 4 servings)

1/4 cup cream cheese
1 tablespoon milk
2 tablespoons confectioner’s sugar
1/8 teaspoon vanilla

Beat all ingredients together in a bowl until smooth in consistency.

Cost Calculator
(for 1 quart of ice cream and 4 servings of sauce)

2 cups plus 1 tablespoon milk (at $4.50/half gallon): $0.75
1 cup heavy cream: $1.29
5 egg yolks (at $3/dozen): $0.63
1/2 cup shredded carrots (at $3/big bag): $0.20
1/4 cup raisins (at $2.50/lb): $0.20
1/3 cup white sugar: $0.15
1/4 cup brown sugar: $0.15
1/4 cup chopped pecans: $0.50
1/4 cup cream cheese: $0.40
2 tablespoons confectioner’s sugar: $0.10
cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, vanilla: $0.35

Total: $4.72

Health Factor

Seven brownie points: For all my bellyaching about binge ice cream eating, I must say there are some redeeming qualities about this one. Not that it’s ever good to go overboard, but there have been worse ice creams to do so with. Although I followed the rules toward making a decidedly rich, creamy base with the amount of egg yolks used, I thought it would be somewhat necessary given juices from carrot blending into it. But those juices add a bit of Vitamin A, and the raisins, a tiny dose of immune-building antioxidants. Of course where milk is concerned there’s plenty of calcium. But ice cream is also where plenty of sugar and cholesterol is concerned.

Green Factor

Five maple leaves: The Greenmarket gets the win for the carrots. But for much of the other ingredients, it’s a tie. I had to run out and grab some more eggs, along with cream, so I was able to get cage-free eggs but only generic cream. As for raisins, it seems like they’re only made in California. I could be wrong, but manufacturers certainly like to advertise them as such.

27 Responses

  1. winnie

    Genius. Sheer genius.

  2. Christina

    Looks delicious, and I’m so impressed by your ice cream creativity. Great post!

  3. kiki

    Oh my. Another amazing creation from your delightful kitchen!

  4. Laura Rebecca

    Oh, mmmm. Very *very* nice idea!

  5. sarah

    oh my god i am drooling.

  6. Haley

    We would like to feature this recipe on our blog. Please email [email protected] if interested. Thanks 🙂


  7. Erin

    I can’t even function now. All I can think about is this ice cream. Absolutely brilliant idea!

  8. […] Not Eating Out in New York » Blog Archive » Carrot Cake Ice Cream with Cream Cheese Sauce […]

  9. Jenna

    Sounds amazing, looks like I know what is going into the new icecream maker next.

    One thing you forgot when figuring out the health side of this. You COOKED the carrots… and everyone knows carrots are one of the few veggies out there that improve their nutritional content by cooking. So essentially, this is better for you then simply crunching down on a carrot!

  10. Julia

    what an awesome idea! i’m glad it turned out well for you. if only i had an ice cream maker 🙁

  11. Michelle

    Carrot cake ice cream! cool. looks yummy.Can you do red velvet next?

  12. bibliochef

    MMM. I am on a bit of an ice cream binge these days so this was just the right post for me!

  13. Culinarywannabe

    This is the first time I’ve stopped by your blog, and I about fell out of my chair! This looks incredible!! I’m on a huge ice cream making spree (although it’s been mostly sorbet making for the summer) and will definitely be trying this soon. Thanks!

  14. Hypatia

    And now no matter what flavour I make with my ice cream maker, the boyfriend will say, “Is is carrot cake ice cream?”
    You’ve spoiled him! That’s the last time I let him browse this website!!! Hahahaa.

    I can’t wait to surprise him. 😀

  15. Lisa

    That is just decadent!

  16. Jen

    I LOVE this, it is so innovative. Plus, carrot cake is my bro’s favorite ice cream. If you’re cooking for yourself, may as well make it something you can’t get anywhere!

    P.S. Have you ever tried to make something similar to a pinkberry yogurt at home? I can’t find that in stores yet.

  17. Michael

    Sounds fantastic!! One thing though – do you think that this can be made without an ice cream machine and if so, what do I need to do?
    I am a big fan of your site and really love the entire concept behind it. Keep up the good work!

  18. irishbasket

    This is a great idea. I will put in my cookbook for company! Thanks.

  19. […] wanted to incorporate both Eastern and Western elements, we added shredded carrots (a la a previous Carrot Cake Ice Cream experiment), making it Curry Carrot Ice […]

  20. Cristina Puerto Rico!

    Hey, stopped by your site by coincidence, thank God for that, its in my favorites now!!Perfect combo!!! Love it!! Carrot Cake Ice Cream Weekend it is!! Woohoo!!!

  21. Hypatia

    Oh man, the boyfriend is going to get such a wonderful surprise! I can’t wait to make it!

  22. Hypatia

    The only other way I know how to make ice cream is with liquid nitrogen. Have any friends in biotech? 😀 Just mix up the ingredients, add liquid nitrogen while stirring, and instant ice cream!!

  23. Culinspiration

    wow. this is inspired!

  24. child minding

    child minding…

    Carrot Cake Ice Cream with Cream Cheese Sauce » Not Eating Out in New York…

  25. jakety ghoust

    you can always ask for a rewriting…

    and you do not need to pay the outsourced worker until you are completely satisfied with the quality of the work….

  26. click here

    easier.besides being able to concentrate, your child…

    needs to be able to communicate his ideas. if he cannot communicate well, his teacher will not be able to understand his point of view. one way to become a good communicator, especially in written form, is to read widely. encourage…

  27. diana

    DId you ever try swirling the cream cheese sauce in the ice-cream?

Leave a Reply